Skip to content

Earnings call

Indian Energy Exchange Q2 FY25 earnings call: The CEA forecast peak power demand of 458 gigawatt by 2032, and power consumption growth will continue to drive exchange volume growth

By . Assembled by software from the company's transcript. Not reviewed by a person.

Transcript filed .

The CEA forecast peak power demand of 458 gigawatt by 2032, and power consumption growth will continue to drive exchange volume growth. About 100 million units of un-requisitioned power from central generating stations is coming to the exchange platform, of which 15 million to 20 million units are cleared on a daily basis. IEX revised its transaction fee on RECs from INR20 per certificate to INR10 per certificate on either side of the transaction, effective 12th August, 2024, consequent to the reduction in REC prices.

The numbers management gave

Results

  • About 100 million units of un-requisitioned power from central generating stations is coming to the exchange platform, of which 15 million to 20 million units are cleared on a daily basis.
    Show source
    As a result, about 100 million units of URS power from central generating stations is coming to the exchange platform, out of which 15 million to 20 million unit is getting cleared on daily business.
  • IEX recorded total trading volume of 36.7 billion units in the quarter ended September 30, 2024, up 38.2% year-on-year.
    Show source
    We recorded a total trading volume of 36.7 billion units in this quarter with a growth of 38.2% on year -on-year basis.
  • IEX traded volume was 67 billion units in the first half of FY '25, up 30% over the same period in FY '24.
    Show source
    For the first half of FY '25, IEX traded volume of 67 billion units, a growth of 30% over the same period in FY '24.
  • IEX traded 63 lakhs certificates in the quarter ended September 30, 2024, up 277% over the same quarter last fiscal.
    Show source
    In Q2, a total of 63 lakhs certificates were traded, a jump of 277% over the same quarter last fiscal.
  • IEX RTM volumes were nearly 11 billion units in the quarter ended September 30, 2024, up 31% year-on-year.
    Show source
    For Q2 FY '25, RTM volumes were higher by 31% Y-o-Y at nearly 11 billion units, showcasing its critical role in developing Discoms and open access consumer efficiently manage short-term electricity needs.
  • On a consolidated basis, IEX revenue grew 26.2% year-on-year to INR167.8 crores in Q2 FY '25 from INR133 crores in Q2 FY '24.
    Show source
    On a consolidated basis, revenue for the company grew 26.2% on year-on-year basis in Q2 FY '25, increasing to INR167.8 crores from INR133 crores in Q2 FY '24.
Show 4 more statements

Results

  • IEX consolidated PAT increased 25.2% to INR108.3 crores in quarter 2 of FY '25 from INR86.5 crores in quarter 2 of FY '24.
    Show source
    Consolidated PAT increased by 25.2%, rising to INR108.3 crores in quarter 2 of FY '25 compared with INR86.5 crores in quarter 2 of FY '24.
  • IGX traded volume was 118 lakh MMBtu in Q2 FY '25 compared with 195 lakh MMBtu in Q2 last fiscal.
    Show source
    IGX traded volume of 118 lakh MMBtu for Q2 FY '25 compared with 195 lakh MMBtu traded in Q2 last fiscal.
  • IGX profit after tax was INR6.1 crores in Q2 FY '25 compared with INR7.8 crores in Q2 FY '24.
    Show source
    Profit after tax for IGX for Q2 FY '25 came in at INR6.1 crores compared with INR7.8 crores in Q2 FY '24.
  • IGX recorded PAT of INR13.6 crores in the first half of FY '25, up 20.7% compared with the same period last fiscal.
    Show source
    For the first half of FY '25, IGX recorded a PAT of INR13.6 crores, higher by 20.7% compared to the same period last fiscal.

What it expects ahead

What management expects

  • The CEA forecast peak power demand of 458 gigawatt by 2032, and power consumption growth will continue to drive exchange volume growth.
    Show source
    With the CEA forecast of peak power demand of 458 gigawatt by 2032, power consumption growth will continue to drive exchange volume growth.
  • Generating stations within the States will start offering un-requisitioned power on the exchange, further increasing liquidity on the exchanges.
    Show source
    Soon generating stations which are within the States will start to offer URS power on the exchange, which will further increase liquidity on the exchanges.
  • Prices on the exchange provide enough arbitrage to make BESS commercially viable at the current prices, which will improve liquidity during non-solar hours and help meet peak hour demand.
    Show source
    Prices on the exchange provide enough arbitrage to make BESS commercially viable at the current prices.
  • The regulatory changes are expected to improve sell-side liquidity and soften power prices, creating an opportunity for DISCOMS and Commercial & Industrial consumers to optimize power procurement costs. Replaced by a later filing.
    Show source
    These changes are expectedly positive for exchanges and are bound to improve sell -side liquidity and soften power prices.
  • Gas volumes are expected to pick up as winter approaches, following stable gas prices over the last two quarters. Replaced by a later filing.
    Show source
    Gas prices have remained stable over the last two quarters, and volumes are expected to pick up as we approach the winter months.
  • The Ministry of Power's initiatives on renewables and thermal capacity addition will keep power procurement cost stable. Replaced by a later filing.
    Show source
    On the liquidity side, MoPs initiative on renewables and thermal capacity addition will keep power procurement cost stable.

What it is building and selling

Demand and pricing

  • IEX revised its transaction fee on RECs from INR20 per certificate to INR10 per certificate on either side of the transaction, effective 12th August, 2024, consequent to the reduction in REC prices.
    Show source
    Consequent to reduction in REC prices, we revised our transaction fee on RECs from INR20 per certificate to INR10 per certificate on either side of transaction with effect from 12th August, 2024.
  • Battery storage rates in the recent tender of NVVN came down to about INR2.37 lakh per megawatt per month under the VGF scheme, from about INR10 lakh per megawatt per month a year ago.
    Show source
    But rates in the recent tender of NVVN have come down to about INR2.37 lakh per megawatt per month under the VGF scheme.

Segments

  • IEX is working with stakeholders to evaluate business diversification opportunities in the EPR trading and settlement platform segment for plastic packaging.
    Show source
    We are working with stakeholders to evaluate business diversification opportunity in this segment.

Risks, rules and outside factors

Rules and policy

  • The Deviation Settlement Mechanism Regulation 2024 made deviation management more stringent, and deviation charges are again linked to grid frequency under the proposed amendments.
    Show source
    The Deviation Settlement Mechanism Regulation 2024 has made deviation management more stringent.
  • The deviation percentage allowed for levy for solar and wind generators has been narrowed to 10%.
    Show source
    With regards solar and wind generators. deviation percentage allowed for levy has been narrowed to 10%.
  • The Ministry of Power recently extended the Section 11 directive to imported coal-based plants to operate up to 31st December 2024, to meet country demand and support liquidity on the exchanges.
    Show source
    To meet high power demand, the MoP recently extended Section 11 directive to imported coal - based plants to operate up to 31st December 2024.
  • The Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission introduced stringent compliance norms for obligated entities under provisions of the Energy Conservation Act 2001.
    Show source
    Under provisions of Energy Conservation Act 2001, the Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission has introduced stringent compliance norms for obligated entities.
  • The Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission introduced a traditional penalty of up to INR3.72 per unit for shortfall in specified renewable energy consumption targets when an obligated entity does not fulfill its renewable purchase obligation and does not purchase certificates.
    Show source
    In the event an obligated entity does not fulfill its renewal purchase obligation and also does not purchase the certificates, the Commission has introduced payment of traditional penalty up to INR3.72 per unit for shortfall in the specified renewable energy consumption targets.
  • The Central Electricity Authority has allowed generating stations selling cross-border power through a dedicated transmission line to facilitate sale of power within India if capacity is not scheduled for a sustained period or a generator issues a default notice for delayed debt payment under their respective PPA.
    Show source
    With regards to cross border electricity market, the C EA has allowed generating stations selling cross border power through a dedicated transmission line to facilitate sale of power within India in case of sustained non -scheduling of capacity or default notice issued by a generator for debt delayed payment under their respective PPA.
Show 1 more statement

Rules and policy

  • The Central Electricity Regulatory Commission recently issued an order to ensure adequacy of resources and identify generation, demand response capacity and generation flexibility requirements to address seasonal variations in electricity demand.
    Show source
    To address challenges posed by seasonal variations in electricity demand, which led to sharp surge in power consumption during crunch periods, the C ERC recently issued an order to ensure adequacy of resources, identify generation, demand response capacity and generation flexibility requirements.

Everything else said on the call

What management stressed

  • IEX shall continue with diversification initiatives within the sector to grow them to significant value. Replaced by a later filing.
    Show source
    IEX shall also continue with the diversification initiative within the sector to grow them to significant value.

What the company said on its earnings call, taken from its own transcript. Not advice.

Questions and answers

  1. Question

    Sumit Kishore: Thank you, Neha. Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. On behalf of Axis Capital, I'm pleased to welcome you all for the IEX Q2 FY '25 Earnings Conference Call. We have with us the management team of IEX, which is represented by Mr. S.N. Goel, the Chairman and Managing Director; Mr. Rohit Bajaj, Joint Managing Director; Mr. Vineet Harlalka, Chief Financial Officer; and Ms. Aparna Garg, Head, Investor Relations and Corporate Communications. We will begin with the opening remarks from Mr. Rohit Bajaj, followed by an interactive Q&A session. Over to you, sir.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    Rohit Bajaj: Good afternoon, everyone. I welcome you all to the IEX Earnings Call for Q2 FY '25. With me today on this call are Mr. Satyanarayan Goel, CMD IEX; Mr. Vineet Harlalka, our CFO and Company Secretary; Mr. Amit Kumar, Head of Market Operations, New Product Initiatives & Exchange Technologies; Ms. Aparna Garg, Head of Investor Relations and Communications; and Mr. Aditya Wali. Friends, Modi government 3.0 recently concluded 100 days, maintaining its thrust on infrastructure development, innovation push and economic growth. The Indian economy continues to be the world's fastest major economy with yet another reported quarter of robust GDP growth. The economy grew 6.7% Y-o-Y in Q1 FY '25, allowing the RBI to retain its GDP forecast for FY '25 at 7.2%. In the wake of Q1 GDP growth, the World Bank has also revised its GDP growth projections upwards for FY '25 to 7% from 6.6% projected earlier.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    On the power sector front, electricity demand growth during the second quarter slowed on the back of better-than-expected monsoon. Monsoon was 8% higher than the long-term annual average. Power demand at 435 billion units in Q2 was largely flat at plus 0.5% Y-o-Y with a peak demand of 227 gigawatts. However, in the first six months of FY '25, power demand was higher by 5.6% over the previous year. To meet India's growing energy demand, the Ministry of Power has maintained its focus on capacity addition and strengthening of overall power infrastructure. Almost 28 gigawatt of thermal capacity is under construction, out of which 15 gigawatt is expected to get commissioned in this fiscal and the balance 13 gigawatt in the next 2 years. Further, 58 gigawatt of capacity is in various stages of planning, statutory clearances and bidding and this should come in the system over next six to seven years.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    Capacity addition is being regularly monitored by the Ministry of Power. In addition, 40 to 50 gigawatt of renewable capacity is to be added every year until 2030. The government also plans to add 39 gigawatt of pump storage project, PSP, by 2030, out of a total potential of 184 gigawatt. Recently in September, MNRE issued guidelines for Viability Gap Funding scheme for offshore wind energy projects worth 1 gigawatt across the States of Gujarat and Tamil Nadu. It is Page 2 of 16 Indian Energy Exchange Limited October 25, 2024 proposed in the scheme that any un-requisitioned power from these projects can also be sold on the exchanges. This is expected to increase sell -side liquidity on the exchanges. At the recently concluded Global Energy Investors meet in Gujarat, our Honorable Prime Minister also underscored India's strategic growth to expand its renewable capacity to 500 gigawatt by 2030.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    Energy developers at the meet pledged substantial commitment to capacity creation under their Shapath Patra Agreement. At the event, the government also highlighted plans to develop 17 cities as a model solar cities. On the fuel side, this fiscal has not seen any shortage so far. Coal is available through the e - auction route at a very nominal premium of 10% to 20% with respect to the administered price and coal inventory today stands at about 14 days. Imported coal pri ces in Q2 have also been competitive at $52 per ton. Similarly, gas prices at $12 per MMBtu have remained largely stable in the first half of FY '25. With favorable monsoon this year, high hydro and wind generation and ample availability of fuel has led to higher liquidity on the exchange platform with sell liquidity increasing by 41% over H1 FY '24.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    With these strengths in liquidity, volume growth is expected to continue going forward. Let us now talk about important regulatory updates and policy initiatives that helped deepen power markets. Recently in a draft, the CERC has proposed various changes in term ahead market design, which will align TAM products across exchanges and also help in improving liquidity. The Deviation Settlement Mechanism Regulation 2024 has made deviation management more stringent. This is likely to promote further discipline leading to better grid stability. Under the proposed amendments, deviation charges are again linked to grid frequency. With regards solar and wind generators. deviation percentage allowed for levy has been narrowed to 10%.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    This is expected to further increase RTM volumes at exchanges. With regards to cross border electricity market, the C EA has allowed generating stations selling cross border power through a dedicated transmission line to facilitate sale of power within India in case of sustained non -scheduling of capacity or default notice issued by a generator for debt delayed payment under their respective PPA. This has the potential to increase liquidity on the exchanges. To meet high power demand, the MoP recently extended Section 11 directive to imported coal - based plants to operate up to 31st December 2024. These assets will be utilized to meet country demand and support liquidity on the exchanges. To address challenges posed by seasonal variations in electricity demand, which led to sharp surge in power consumption during crunch periods, the C ERC recently issued an order to ensure adequacy of resources, identify generation, demand response capacity and generation flexibility requirements. Page 3 of 16 Indian Energy Exchange Limited October 25, 2024 Under the amendment to Late Payment Surcharge (LPSC) rules, the government has directed all generating stations, which have long-term PPAs to offer un-requisitioned power on the exchange platform.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    As a result, about 100 million units of URS power from central generating stations is coming to the exchange platform, out of which 15 million to 20 million unit is getting cleared on daily business. Soon generating stations which are within the States will start to offer URS power on the exchange, which will further increase liquidity on the exchanges. Under provisions of Energy Conservation Act 2001, the Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission has introduced stringent compliance norms for obligated entities. In the event an obligated entity does not fulfill its renewal purchase obligation and also does not purchase the certificates, the Commission has introduced payment of traditional penalty up to INR3.72 per unit for shortfall in the specified renewable energy consumption targets. This should promote compliances and help maintain a vibrant REC market. These changes are expectedly positive for exchanges and are bound to improve sell -side liquidity and soften power prices. As prices continue to remain competitive, it is expected to present an opportunity for DISCOMS and Commercial & Industrial consumers to optimize their power procurement costs.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    IEX business performance during Q2 FY '25 has been strong. We recorded a total trading volume of 36.7 billion units in this quarter with a growth of 38.2% on year -on-year basis. For the first half of FY '25, IEX traded volume of 67 billion units, a growth of 30% over the same period in FY '24. Consequent to reduction in REC prices, we revised our transaction fee on RECs from INR20 per certificate to INR10 per certificate on either side of transaction with effect from 12th August, 2024. In Q2, a total of 63 lakhs certificates were traded, a jump of 277% over the same quarter last fiscal. RTM segment has seen strong growth this fiscal. For Q2 FY '25, RTM volumes were higher by 31% Y-o-Y at nearly 11 billion units, showcasing its critical role in developing Discoms and open access consumer efficiently manage short-term electricity needs.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    In September 2024, RTM recorded the highest single day trade volume of 173 million units. And RTM also achieved its highest ever monthly volume of nearly 3.5 billion units. . The share of RTM in our overall product mix has also increased to nearly 30% over the last two quarters from 27% at the end FY '24. RTM's ability to offer flexibility and immediate responsiveness highlights the opportunity to efficiently integrate renewables with the grid. Similarly, for the quarter, Green market volumes rose to 246% to nearly 2.6 billion units as compared with Q2 FY '25. In terms of new products, we continue to await approval from CRC for our long duration contracts. We have already filed a petition with them for approval of 11-month contract on which the hearing has happened and order is reserved.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    Further, we have filed petition with CERC for approval of Green RTM segment. Green RTM would provide opportunity for RE sellers to avail price premium over conventional power and also buyers to avail Green attribute of electricity. This segment shall also help reduction in variation exposure due to weather events by providing an avenue to trade Green power just one hour in advance. Page 4 of 16 Indian Energy Exchange Limited October 25, 2024 We are happy to inform that our wholly-owned subsidiary, International Carbon Exchange has been accredited as India's first renewal energy certificate issuer. I-REC is globally recognized digital certificate that serves as a transferable proof of generation of 1 megawatt hour of energy from renewable sources. Further, the Honorable Minister of Coal, Shri G. Kishan Reddy Ji earlier this week announced that India's first coal exchange would be set up soon and that the exchange would work under the supervision of Coal Controller Organization. IEX has been working with stakeholders to explore this diversification opportunity.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    On another front, in August, the draft guidelines for Authorization and Functioning of Extended Producers Responsibility, EPR Trading and Settlement Platform for Plastic Packaging has been issued by the Central Pollution Control Board. This will help in the transparent and competitive price discovery for EPR certificates through an online platform. EPR certification ensures proper recycling, reuse, end-of-life disposal of waste generated from electronic and plastic products. It is expected that this would be extended to other types of waste, such as e-waste, battery waste, tire waste, used oil waste, etcetera. We are working with stakeholders to evaluate business diversification opportunity in this segment. Let us now summarize the financial performance of the company in this quarter. On a consolidated basis, revenue for the company grew 26.2% on year-on-year basis in Q2 FY '25, increasing to INR167.8 crores from INR133 crores in Q2 FY '24.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    Consolidated PAT increased by 25.2%, rising to INR108.3 crores in quarter 2 of FY '25 compared with INR86.5 crores in quarter 2 of FY '24. IGX traded volume of 118 lakh MMBtu for Q2 FY '25 compared with 195 lakh MMBtu traded in Q2 last fiscal. Profit after tax for IGX for Q2 FY '25 came in at INR6.1 crores compared with INR7.8 crores in Q2 FY '24. For the first half of FY '25, IGX recorded a PAT of INR13.6 crores, higher by 20.7% compared to the same period last fiscal. Gas prices have remained stable over the last two quarters, and volumes are expected to pick up as we approach the winter months. Way forward -- Friencd, the power sector is undergoing rapid visible shift. A year ago, battery storage rates were almost about INR10 lakh per megawatt per month.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    But rates in the recent tender of NVVN have come down to about INR2.37 lakh per megawatt per month under the VGF scheme. The competitive rates in BESS make a promising case for market development. Prices on the exchange provide enough arbitrage to make BESS commercially viable at the current prices. This will improve liquidity during non-solar hours and will help in meeting peak hour demand. With the CEA forecast of peak power demand of 458 gigawatt by 2032, power consumption growth will continue to drive exchange volume growth. On the liquidity side, MoPs initiative on renewables and thermal capacity addition will keep power procurement cost stable. The regulatory environment and government initiative to facilitate the path of energy transition shall continue to support market development.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    IEX shall also continue with the diversification initiative within the sector to grow them to significant value. Page 5 of 16 Indian Energy Exchange Limited October 25, 2024 As India marches towards achieving its net zero target, there is bound to be a growing role of power exchanges in the country’s energy landscape and IEX shall continue to be part of this journey. Thank you. And now we can have questions and answers.

  2. Question

    Mohit Kumar: Good Afternoon Sir! Congratulations on a very good set of numbers. My first question will be, what is your market share in this quarter vis -à-vis other exchanges?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: Our market share has been almost about 83% now.

  3. Question

    Mohit Kumar: Understood, sir. My second question, sir, is on the transaction fees. When we take the revenues and divide by number of units, it seems like the transaction fees for the quarter is INR3.7 per unit. Are we giving a discount?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: In case of REC market, the rates have come down. REC rates are now almost about INR120, INR110. So, we have reduced the transaction fees from the REC. And this is because of that.

  4. Question

    Mohit Kumar: Have they started the pilot or is it still awaited?

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    Rohit Bajaj: We are really not aware about it.

  5. Question

    Mohit Kumar: Okay. Understood sir. Thank you and all the best, sir. Thank you.

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    Rohit Bajaj: What we understand is that they were in the process of developing the software, they were taking the data from us to validate the software. But what has happened in the simulation, we are not aware about that.

  6. Question

    Sumit Kishore: During the September quarter, the REC volumes kept coming off from July, which was a very good month, followed by a lower number in August and further decline in September. What was the dynamic here, although REC in each of these months were much higher tha n the prior period on a year-on-year basis? And what is the likely road map going forward now that REC prices have come off so substantially? Page 6 of 16 Indian Energy Exchange Limited October 25, 2024 SN Goel: Volumes were significantly higher in the month of July because Bihar is one state where there was a lot of deficit and they purchased good amount of RECs.

    Answer, sn goel

    And since they completed their RPO compliance in the month of July by buying significantly higher number of RECs, so in August, September, they were not there, DVC was not there. And because of that, the numbers have reduced. But I'm sure that trend with respect to last year, increasing trend, that will definitely continue because REC rates have come down, and there are many interested parties who are going to do their do their RPO compliance and purchase the REC. Sumit Kishore: Very clear. The second question is that in a quarter where India's power demand growth was barely up 0.5%, IEX electricity volume growth was up 23%. So aside from the factors of better fuel availability, lower cost, better liquidity, were there any other factors or anything structural , which would imply that the momentum of growth would continue going forward as possibly power demand actually may pick up at the all-India level? Your thoughts there, please.

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: Yes, demand is definitely expected to increase. I mean, India is a growing economy. Our GDP is increasing at a rate of 7%. If GDP is increasing. power demand is also going to increase. And government also has taken many initiatives to increase the electricity consumption. And I'm sure the projections are, the demand for electricity is going to increase at a rate of almost about 7% for the next seven, eight years. And if that is the case, then definitely exchange transactions also will increase, because 7% of increase, that is almost about 130 billion units increase.

    Answer, sn goel

    And I'm sure a good part of this incremental demand will come to the market.

  7. Question

    Sumit Kishore: Sure. How is the month of October panning out so far in terms of electricity volume growth?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: It is a growth, but October demand is slightly lower because of the temperature dip in the Northern region and also rains in the South and East. But there is an almost about 8% kind of volume growth.

  8. Question

    Sumit Kishore: Thank you so much Sir.

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: April '23 order did not specify any timeline for the discussion paper. So as of now, to our knowledge, nothing has happened and nothing is happening on that. But as far as transaction fees is concerned, I think this issue has been deliberated multiple times in CERC. In 2018, also CERC order came. And there also, they had allowed 2 paise as transaction fees. It was again allowed in the 2021 regulation and then again, in 2023 orders. Page 7 of 16 Indian Energy Exchange Limited October 25, 2024 And you rightly said, that in case of REC since the rate has reduced, we reduced the transaction fee.

    Answer, sn goel

    But in case of electricity, our transaction fees is continuing at two-paise on either -side right from 2011 when the electricity rates were almost about 2.5, 3rupees. Today, electricity clearing price is almost in the range of INR5. In spite of that, we have not increased the transaction fees. And even if you look, the trading activities, what is happening in the sector, there regulator has allowed transaction fees up to seven paisa per unit. Government of India company SECI, when they are buying power from the renewable generators and selling it to distribution company, they are also allowed a trading margin of seven paise. So, if that is the case, I don't see any reason why this four paise transaction fees will not be allowed or will be considered as high. Bharani: Sure, I think that is good to know.

    Answer, sn goel

    Second question is on market coupling. Now in February 2024, when the result of the initial pilot study was given by CERC, the document talked about doing further pilot study, especially focusing on whether coupling RTM market with SCED market is any beneficial. Now my question is, in layman terms, why should coupling in RTM and SCED be considered. If you can conceptually explain rather than coupling in the overall market?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: See, CERC in the order which was issued in the month of February, they have very clearly mentioned that they did simulation for 3 months. And based on the data, they did not find any merit in coupling only RTM market or only DAM market of the three exchanges. So one of the suggestions which they received was to couple the RTM and the SCED, and just to explore it further, they have given the order to Grid-India to do the simulations and see if there is a merit in that. But let me tell you, SCED and RTM are 2 different kind of markets. SCED is basically among the generating stations who have long-term power purchase agreements where the fixed cost is assured under the PPA. They sell power on the basis of the variable cost, regulated variable cost. In case of RTM market, the generators are merchant generators and they have to recover the fixed and variable cost to the market.

    Answer, sn goel

    And even the coal, which is given to the PPA generators is through the FSA route at the administered price, whereas merchant generators buy coal from the e-auction route. So I think these two are two different sets of generators. So theoretically speaking, coupling between these two set of generators is something not desirable. But then some simulation studies are going on and we also know about, what kind of benefits they're getting in the SCED and how much of volume is getting cleared in the SCED, all this data is available in the public domain. And if you couple these two markets, significant benefit is not going to happen. The incremental benefit is going to be very very low. And I don't think for that kind of a small benefit, CERC will go ahead.

    Answer, sn goel

    I mean implementing this kind of a coupling is very, very cumbersome activity, and it also involves cumbersome financial and physical settlement process. So, I don't think it is worth taking all that pain, but then again we are waiting for that study report and then CERC order thereafter. Bharani: That is very clear. Thanks for answering. Page 8 of 16 Indian Energy Exchange Limited October 25, 2024 Moderator: The next question is from the line of Chirag from Keynote Capital.

  9. Question

    Chirag Maroo: Thank you for the opportunity. Would it be possible for you to give market share product-wise?

    Answer, rohit bajaj

    Rohit Bajaj: Yes. So in day-ahead market and real time market, which are collective segment, our market share is 99.5%. In the term-ahead market, our market share is about 40%, which overall, on a total basis, it makes it 82.7% or 83% in electricity. In certificates, it is 60%. And overall market share in H1, first six months is 79%. Electricity it is 83% and certificates it is 60% and total is around 79%.

  10. Question

    Chirag Maroo: Right. Sir, second, I wanted to understand one thing as the earlier participant also asked, there was one simulation taking place related to RTM and DAM which didn’t make it through because majority of the volumes were used to come from the IEX itself. So even if there is market coupling…if this RTM and SCED based market coupling goes forward also, does that mean all the products will be coupled or it wil l be just two of these products in the market?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: We don't want to comment on that. Let CERC decide about it first. And thereafter, we will talk about this. As of now, the simulatio n is basically for RTM and SCED. Chirag: Sir, third question I just wanted to have a view. Is there any internal discussion in the management team going on related to change in dividend policy? As we don't require this much amount of cash for bringing new products itself, has there been any talks related to slab -based dividend model taking place and changing from the cu rrent 65 percentage of it?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: As of now, there is no such thinking about it. We are giving 65 %-70% kind of profit in the form of dividend and that's a good dividend payout. We are also working on other initiatives as I told you in the past . Gas exchange is doing well. We are also working on coal exchange, which is Government of India, Ministry of Coal is talking about that. And there are EPR trading, discussions going around. Carbon exchange is another opportunity.

    Answer, sn goel

    So I think for all these things, money will be required, so we are keeping that money for that purpose. Chirag: Will it be possible for you to give a broad ballpark number wherein -- what kind of money would be required for bringing these …?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: See, even in case of power exchange also since we are co unterparty to both the sides, we have to make payment to the sellers even if we are not getting payment from a buyer. And there have been some instances where there was one or two days delay in making the payment by the buyer. So we have to have enough surplus fund with the company to take care of this kind of eventuality. So I think the present surplus is about INR900 crores which includes the investors' money, which is available in the company. It is not very high. But then yes, in future, we can think about a special dividend if there is a need. Chirag: Fair enough.

Show 4 more questions
  1. Question

    Viraj Mithani: Congratulations Sir, for the good set of numbers. My question is again on coupling. In case the coupling goes through, so how are we going to be affected. Like, I mean, because we are the leading exchange in the -- we have first-mover advantage too. Can you give some color on that? I know it's too early to comment, but if you can give?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: I'm very sure coupling is not going to happen. So let us not worry about that. And in case coupling happens, we have ways and means to ensure that we are able to retain our market share. And we will talk about the details when we come to that.

  2. Question

    Devesh Agarwal: Good afternoon sir and thank you for the opportunity. Firstly, again on continuing on market coupling, if you could help us understand whether this URS power that has been coming into the RTM market, in any way does that kind of bring down the benefit that could have possibly come out by coupling the SCED with RTM market or it doesn't impact?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: See, number one, SCED volume itself is very less. It was earlier about 30, 35 million units per day whereas the RTM market volume is about 100 million units. And after this government new rule of sale of URS power on the exchange platform, we are seeing that in the RTM market, on an average daily about 20 million units of this URS power is being sold through the market itself. So that means that opportunity available for further optimization in the SCED market is further reduced. So today, the SCED market is less than 28 million units per day. So I think the optimization opportunity is definitely further reduced. And if all generators, they participate in the DAM and RTM market, the URS power is sold, there will be practically no optimization opportunity by coupling SCED and RTM.

    Answer, sn goel

    Devesh Agarwal: Understood, sir. And secondly, sir, if we see the numbers for October, you said there is some growth. But if we see for our numbers in the month of October, we are seeing that there is a month-on-month decline. And the decline is largely in the RTM segment where volumes have come down by 20 to 25 MUs on a daily basis. So any particular reason for this, sir?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: Yes, month-on-month, there is a decline. But if you look at year-on-year, there is a positive number. And month-on-month, month of September is slightly hotter and humid month. Agriculture demand is also there because of that, the demand was high in the country. Now demand also has reduced. And fortunately, availability of generating units is high. So that is why I think volume is on a month -on-month basis reduced.

    Answer, sn goel

    Our comparison is mainly on a year-on-year basis. Because you will see on every month, I mean next year, November is going to be further colder month and the demand may further go down. But if you compare with respect to last year, that is the basic comparison what we do. Page 10 of 16 Indian Energy Exchange Limited October 25, 2024 Devesh Agarwal: Understood, sir.

  3. Question

    And sir, I think you touched upon in your introductory remarks, this CERC regulation, which came at the start of the month around TAM pricing. Could you just explain a bit better what does the draft paper talks about? And how would this impact the TAM market? And does this benefit or impact us in any ways if this were to be implemented?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: See, first, it is basically to streamline the transactions in the TAM market. Today, there are multiple products and exchanges were given the flexibility to introduce whatever product they feel like. And as a result of that, different exchanges have introduced different kind of products. So there is no standardization in that. And that is why the liquidity in this market is getting fragmented across these different products. So CERC has now decided to streamline this activity, and there will be standard products available in the market so that buyers and sellers can see what is available for the sell and what is what they want to buy. And I think this is a very good initiative of the CERC and it is good for the market.

  4. Question

    Devesh Agarwal: But does it impact any of our segment volumes or no, not really?

    Answer, sn goel

    SN Goel: It doesn't impact that and I'm sure we'll be a larger beneficiary of this.

Questions about this call

When was the Indian Energy Exchange Q2 FY25 earnings call transcript filed?
Indian Energy Exchange filed the transcript with the exchange on 29 Oct 2024. This page is built from that transcript.
What does this page list?
27 statements from the transcript across 6 topics, 16 of them with a figure. Each statement is shown with the transcript sentence it came from.
Are the analysts' questions included?
Yes. 14 questions and management's answers are listed in the order they were asked, as the transcript prints them.
Who wrote this page?
DalalOS Data Desk. Assembled by software from the company's transcript. Not reviewed by a person. How it is made, and what it leaves out, is on the method page linked from the byline.
Research and analysis only, not investment advice. Every statement on this page is the company's own, taken from its transcript; DalalOS adds no view on it and is not a SEBI-registered investment adviser. Something wrong? Report an error.
Indian Energy Exchange Q2 FY25 concall: The CEA forecast peak power demand of 458 gigawatt by 2032, and power consumption growth will continue to drive exchange volume growth · DalalOS