Earnings call
TVS Motor Company Q2 FY27 earnings call: TVS Motor expects the ICE segment in both 2-wheeler and 3-wheeler to grow single digit, based on overall activities and overall GDP growth
By DalalOS Data Desk. Assembled by software from the company's transcript. Not reviewed by a person.
Transcript filed .
The transcript names the quarter but not the year. The year is worked out from the date it was filed.
TVS Motor expects the ICE segment in both 2-wheeler and 3-wheeler to grow single digit, based on overall activities and overall GDP growth. TVS Motor is operating EV capacity of around 60,000 to 65,000, including domestic sales and exports, and is enhancing capacity to about 80,000, with activities already underway. TVS Motor grew ahead of the industry in every market in the second quarter of this financial year, and its international 3-wheeler market performed very well. EV penetration in 2-wheelers reached 11.6% in September, measured against total 2-wheelers.
The numbers management gave
Results
- TVS Motor grew ahead of the industry in every market in the second quarter of this financial year, and its international 3-wheeler market performed very well.
Show source
So every market has done well, and we have grown ahead of the industry in every market.
- TVS Motor started selling EVs in international markets last year, and sold about 6,930 units in the second quarter of this financial year.
Show source
Now in Q2, we have done about 6,930 units.
- TVS Motor's PLI benefit was about 1.3% to 1.4% of turnover, and it had crossed 10,000 cumulative and was receiving a 2% benefit.
Show source
I think it's about 1.3%, 1.4% of the turnover.
- TVS Motor increased selling prices by 1.6% against a material cost increase of almost 1.9% from Q1 to Q2.
Show source
But price increases, we are also very close so for example, Q1 to Q2, the material cost increase was almost 1.9%, and we have increased selling prices by 1.6%.
- TVS Motor's 2-wheeler ICE business grew almost 15% in the first half of this financial year; growth was 10% in the first quarter and almost double in the second quarter.
Show source
So we saw 10% in the first quarter, but we saw almost double in the second quarter, okay.
- TVS Motor is balancing unprecedented material cost increases against customers' ability to pay, with a focus on material cost reduction and product mix; it raises prices where appropriate and uses variants to obtain better prices.
Show source
So this is a journey, both in domestic, Page 9 of 17 TVS Motor Company Limited October 28, 2026 international, 2-wheeler, 3-wheeler, we'll be very closely monitoring and like I said last time, this time, the material cost increases are unprecedented, but we also look at the ability of the customer.
Show 1 more statement
Results
- The company partially mitigated commodity price increases in Q1 and Q2 through cost reduction and optimization initiatives on product mix.
Show source
We are able to partially mitigate through the cost reduction, also optimization initiatives on product mix.
What it expects ahead
What management expects
- TVS Motor expects the ICE segment in both 2-wheeler and 3-wheeler to grow single digit, based on overall activities and overall GDP growth.
Show source
Based on that, we are expecting that you will see the ICE segment both in 2-wheeler and 3- wheeler to grow single digit.
- TVS Motor expects EVs to continue growing, with very good growth, and expects momentum to continue after significant growth in quarter 1.
Show source
On the EV, EV will continue to keep up the momentum, and you will see very good growth, okay.
- TVS Motor expects to grow ahead of the market domestically and ahead of the industry internationally in both 2-wheeler and 3-wheeler, and expects to be ahead of the industry in the forthcoming quarter and Q4 as it enhances capacity.
Show source
It will grow and TVS with the kind of portfolios what we have and the capacity what we are enhancing, we are very confident that we will be ahead of the industry in the forthcoming quarter and in Q4 now before I conclude, I just wanted to once again explain the demerger in detail.
- TVS Motor expects Ronin to go beyond 15,000 and is preparing for that level; capacity expansion takes about 3 months.
Show source
Last time I told you, we are now confident that it will go beyond 15,000.
- The company expects good single-digit growth in Q3, while cautioning against expecting the similar 15.8% growth seen in H1 because of the base effect from the industry's huge growth in November and December last year.
Show source
That is the reason I said good single-digit growth can be expected in Q3.
- Management expects scooters to reach 45% next year and potentially 50% in a couple of years, attributing the growth to customer preference.
Show source
I won't be surprised next year, you will see 45% scooters, and it can even go up to 50% in a couple of years.
Show 10 more statements
What management expects
- The company expects Ronin volumes to grow from 1,000 and 2,000 numbers to 15,000 numbers.
Show source
Marketing, you for example, Ronin, we started with 1,000 numbers and 2,000 numbers, Now I'm confident that we'll come to 15,000 numbers.
- The company expects customer demand for its products to be extremely positive and good going forward in 2-wheelers and 3-wheelers across markets in India and abroad.
Show source
And I am pretty confident that going forward, the customer demand for TVS's products are extremely positive and good and both in 2-wheelers, 3-wheelers and many markets in India as well as in abroad.
- TVS Motor expects much higher growth in the third and fourth quarters of this financial year.
Show source
You will see much higher growth from TVS in quarter 3 and quarter 4.
- Norton is developing further new models, some of which will be announced in EICMA next week.
Show source
Some of them will be announced in EICMA next week.
- TVS Motor expects EV momentum to continue in Q3.
Show source
And this momentum is likely to continue even in Q3.
- The company considers further cost increases in Q3 and Q4 unlikely, though small increases may occur; management is hopeful costs will stabilize or soften slightly in Q4.
Show source
Q4, definitely, I'm hopeful that things should stabilize or even you will see some small softening, okay?
- The company expects margin to continue to grow as top-line growth flows through to EBITDA and PBT.
Show source
K. N. Radhakrishnan: Margin will continue to grow because when the top line is growing, I'm very sure that is going to also fall through into EBITDA journey.
- TVS Motor expects its India launch in the forthcoming months. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
India launch is expected to be in the forthcoming months.
- The company is confident its products will do very well next financial year. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
So I'm pretty confident that our products will do very well even the next year, financial year.
- The company expects to continue its EBITDA journey going forward. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
And we are confident that we will continue the momentum on our EBITDA journey going forward.
What it is building and selling
Projects and capacity
- TVS Motor is operating EV capacity of around 60,000 to 65,000, including domestic sales and exports, and is enhancing capacity to about 80,000, with activities already underway.
Show source
We are now operating around 60,000 to 65,000, and we are also exporting, okay.This includes both domestic plus exports, what we are doing, India market plus exports.
- The company expects to cross more than 8 million 2-wheeler capacity and reach almost 0.4 million 3-wheeler capacity soon.
Show source
I think as I told you, we will cross more than 8 million 2- wheeler capacity.
- The company is enhancing Orbiter capacity in Q4, which management said would help Orbiter growth.
Show source
And fortunately, capacity-wise, we are also enhancing the capacity in Q4.
- The company will invest behind its capacity expansion and will plan capacity for next year because market pull is pretty good.
Show source
And we also said that we will be investing behind that.
- Norton is setting up a network in many countries in Europe while building its brand and launching in many countries in Europe. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
Now we are setting up a very strong network in many countries in Europe.
- The company is enhancing capacity and is mindful of total supply chain health as it looks at pull models. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
And we want to look at the pull models, like I said, we are also enhancing capacity, okay.
Show 7 more statements
Demand and pricing
- EV penetration in 2-wheelers reached 11.6% in September, measured against total 2-wheelers.
Show source
I just want to highlight the EV penetration in 2-wheelers in September, it has reached 11.6%, okay.
- EV penetration among scooters was almost 22% in September.
Show source
If you look at only scooters, it is almost 22%.
- 3-wheeler EV penetration was almost 47%.
Show source
So 2-wheelers is moving very well and 3-wheeler EV is also almost 47%.
- The category share of scooters has gone up to 41%.
Show source
ICE plus EV, as I speak, the category share of scooters have gone up to 41%.
- ICE scooters have maintained market share, with ICE at around 32%, 33%.
Show source
I think ICE is at around 32%, 33%, healthy.
- The first half had only 2% growth.
Show source
But I'm of the view that the momentum, while whatever you saw in the first half, we saw almost 15% growth.
- TVS Motor made small selling price increases in the early part of Q3 and will review pricing after Diwali.
Show source
Post Diwali, we will be reviewing.
Everything else said on the call
Group structure
- The consumer finance-related business undertaking of TVS Motor will be demerged into a separate holding company.
Show source
The consumer finance-related business undertaking of TVS Motor will be demerged into a separate holding company.
- Shareholders of TVS Motor will receive an equal number of shares in the resulting company as in TVS Motor.
Show source
The shareholders of TVS Motor will receive equal number of shares in the resulting company as in TVS Motor, enabling them to participate in future growth of both the mobility business and consumer finance business, okay.
What the company said on its earnings call, taken from its own transcript. Not advice.
Questions and answers
Question
K. Gopala Desikan: Absolutely, absolutely.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: Thank you for your good wishes, and it has been a great journey, and I'll continue to be associated with TVS, and there is a strong operating team here where one of the key roles is to also make sure that there is a succession planning and there is a smoot h transition. So all of you can be rest assured that the future leadership will do better than what the current leadership is doing.
Question
Amyn Pirani: Sure. And sir, just one question on the revenue beat and the strong ASP. Can you also highlight how much is the PLI that you're getting right now? And has there been an enhancement in the level or percentage of PLI benefit that you're getting because of th e growth in the EVs, if you can share that?
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: Yes. I think it's about 1.3%, 1.4% of the turnover. And we have also crossed the 10,000 cumulative. So we are also getting that I think what is it called, that 2%.
Question
Amyn Pirani: Boost rate, I think. Page 8 of 17 TVS Motor Company Limited October 28, 2026 K. N. Radhakrishnan: And I think they have certain slabs every quarter, certain numbers.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
I think we are on course. We are on course because our EV proportion is also growing. Numbers are growing on 2-wheeler, numbers are growing in 3-wheelers. So it is a good journey. Thanks to government here.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: Quarter after quarter, it is improving. I think we focus on the margin and margin is improving. I think same strategy overall, we are looking at increasing the scale. We are also coming up with certain variants. So I think the same strategy, whatever I explained on the ICE, we are using here, and we are in the right direction because ultimately, we have to improve along with the top line, we want to also improve the bottom line. So very full focused work is going on, on EV, and we are happy on the journey so far.
Question
Kapil R. Singh: Sir, any colour where are we right now in terms of gross profit, profitability or EBITDA profitability for both?
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: See, I told you, overall, you are able to see the number for the company. We first look at as an overall company, are we growing the top line? and are we growing the EBITDA and the bottom line because we believe in investment in the right technology and which we are doing. We came up with iQube, then we came up with the variants in iQube, then we came up with Orbiter. We are also planning new products. And on the other side, 3-wheeler we came up, we came up with the cargo. So this is a journey, and we keep investing, and we want to delight the customers, both in domestic and international. So this journey will continue.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
And overall, we want to take a healthy portfolio growth in the contribution to the gross margin. And along with it, we want to also grow our EBITDA and PBT. Kapil R. Singh: Okay. Sir, what is just a question on the margins as well. What is the pricing we have taken in this quarter so far in the October to December quarter? And what are you seeing on the cost outlook?
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: October to December also, we have taken some small increases at the beginning. We are also very closely monitoring. There are some increases this quarter also expected, but may not be huge. If you look at Q1 to Q2 itself, you would have seen we have not there is only a small increase in the material cost. But price increases, we are also very close so for example, Q1 to Q2, the material cost increase was almost 1.9%, and we have increased selling prices by 1.6%. Now early part of Q3, we are also small increases we have done, but we will be reviewing very closely this month. Post Diwali, we will be reviewing.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
So this is a journey, both in domestic, Page 9 of 17 TVS Motor Company Limited October 28, 2026 international, 2-wheeler, 3-wheeler, we'll be very closely monitoring and like I said last time, this time, the material cost increases are unprecedented, but we also look at the ability of the customer. So we are prudent on both sides balancing. And we also have a strong material cost reduction focus and product mix. And wherever we are able to price it appropriately, we come up with higher prices. And we also certain variants, we are able to get better prices. So it's a combination of top line growth, mix, selling price increase, also material cost reduction. I think it is a combination of the portfolio is what we always look at.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: I think the most important for anybody in any company is all our customers. So I want to again and again thank all my customers, all TVS Motor customers. I think they have made us come here. So again and again, I want to thank the customers. Now coming to this industry growth, if you ask me in a couple of weeks, we will get a better view because we have seen the season. Now the most important Dussehra, we are all waiting on November 6. I'm eagerly looking forward to that.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
But I'm of the view that the momentum, while whatever you saw in the first half, we saw almost 15% growth. Q1, we saw only the total growth was almost 15.8%. I'm saying only 2 -wheeler ICE, okay, not including EV here. So we saw 10% in the first quarter, but we saw almost double in the second quarter, okay. So and even the season on a higher base, it is good according to me. So that is the kind of momentum we can expect in Q3. But we'll have to wait.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
If you ask me, I'll wait for a couple of weeks just to see how things pan out. Definitely, the customer needs are there. But equally, I see there is a pressure in the market because the industry last year in the month of November, December, we saw a huge growth. So the base effect will be there. That is the reason I said single-digit growth, okay. I'm optimistic, but we have to be very cautious because you know expecting the similar 15.8% growth what you saw in H1, okay, we have to be a little cautious. That is the reason I said good single-digit growth can be expected in Q3.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
Again, end of Q3, we can look at Q4, how is it going to pan out. Last year, Q4 was also extremely good for ICE. So that is the way I would like to summarize. Chandramouli: And you speak to your commentary that TVS should be able to outgrow the industry during this period. Page 10 of 17 TVS Motor Company Limited October 28, 2026 K. N. Radhakrishnan: Surely.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
I'm pretty confident about that because I think we keep right stocks in the market. Everything is cash and carry. I think even now, I don't think we have more than possibly maximum 30 days of stock. Many dealers are less than 21 days of stock, okay. And thanks to customers, they have many pull models in the market. So that is going to definitely help TVS in the month of November and December, and we will continue our momentum, not only November, December, even last quarter and thereon because we definitely believe in keeping the right stock and keeping this band of 21 to 30 days of stock with the dealers. Same principle we use in the international.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
And we want to look at the pull models, like I said, we are also enhancing capacity, okay. And we are very mindful about the total supply chain health. So I'm pretty confident that our products will do very well even the next year, financial year. Chandramouli: Got it. That's helpful. Second question is just around the Orbiters. I know you're getting PLI scheme incentive on the Orbiters.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
And when we've seen higher oil prices over the past 6 months, there's been a big spike in electric 2-wheeler penetration. Orbiter looks like it's coming up to about 20% of your domestic electric 2-wheeler sales mix in less than a year since launch. So I just want to understand over the next 1 or 2 years, where you see urban electric scooter penetration right now and where that can move in your view? And what role you think Orbiter has to play? Is there sort of mix that you think Orbiter can reach within your electric 2-wheeler portfolio from the current 20%?
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: See Orbiter to be very honest, we had we gave higher priority for iQube initially to take it to the next level. Now Orbiter, we are now focusing to support every market. So orbiter availability has gone up. Orbiter also, we have started exporting. Orbiter is unique in its design and customer segment. I think iQube is a typical scooter for the family. And Orbiter is a little different.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
And you can see the characteristic of Orbiter. And I'm very sure orbiter will also grow. More and more orbiter, you will see in the market, you will see. And fortunately, capacity-wise, we are also enhancing the capacity in Q4. That is also going to help. Now when you talk about next 3 years, I'm of the view that I think we have to look at together scooters. ICE plus EV, as I speak, the category share of scooters have gone up to 41%.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
If you recollect my discussions in the past quarters, there was a worry or an anxiety or a risk, which was that ICE scooters will come down, EV scooters as we come. Actually, what has happened is ICE has maintained. ICE not lost market share. I think ICE is at around 32%, 33%, healthy. On top of it, you are saying 9%, 10% so what has happened is scooter as a category, I can let you know that it is going to further grow, okay. I won't be surprised next year, you will see 45% scooters, and it can even go up to 50% in a couple of years. So this is because the customers love it.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
It has got its own convenience; it has got its own benefit. And we have seen it is affecting the other commuting class. So fortunately, TVS has got the right products in both ICE, Jupiter and on one side and on the other side, Orbiter and iQube. So that is the way I would like to answer your question. Page 11 of 17 TVS Motor Company Limited October 28, 2026 Chandramouli: Got it. Just lastly, a housekeeping question on export and spares revenue, if you could share for the quarter, please?
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: Before coming to cost first, I want to say, like I answered that still the demand for TVS products in the market is extremely good and positive. And even now, we are operating maybe between 21 days to 30 days of stock for most of the models in the market, okay? So we have to consistently deliver what the market wants, and we are also investing behind capacity. This is applicable both in domestic, international, 3-wheeler, 3-wheeler ICE, 3-wheeler EV everywhere. So I'm pretty confident that we will continue to maintain the revenue growth, again, here only because of customer. The moment you are able to grow your revenue and your total volume ahead of the industry, that gives you a lot of flexibility in terms of looking at variance, product mix, and we can also look at what can be done better, okay. And please remember, the material cost this year, Q1, Q2, whatever we have seen, I don't think the kind of increases you will see in Q3 and Q4.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
We have always seen this is a cycle. When the cost goes up, it goes up for maybe 2 quarters, 3 quarters, then it will a little bit soften or it will remain same, okay. So the cost increases happen on the first day of every month. Price increases doesn't happen and cost reduction also doesn't happen. So we have to give a little bit of time. So we have to very closely look at and evaluate how the customers are looking at it, how the demand is happening in the market. So we are always we always look at the top line growth and the customer satisfaction most important, leading to these changes.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
So I'm of the view that Q3 and Q4 the kind of cost increases, whatever you have seen in Q1 and Q2, further increases are unlikely. Maybe small increases may be there, okay? Q4, definitely, I'm hopeful that things should stabilize or even you will see some small softening, okay? Page 12 of 17 TVS Motor Company Limited October 28, 2026 This is on the cost increases. Now coming to I think you highlighted about some of the employee costs, marketing costs. Please understand we are looking at a long-term journey. Marketing, you for example, Ronin, we started with 1,000 numbers and 2,000 numbers, Now I'm confident that we'll come to 15,000 numbers.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
We are not disproportionately increasing our marketing costs, but we need to invest in the brand.. And when you invest in the brand, you are definitely likely to get better and better results in the future quarters. Whatever revenue I'm getting today is all because of the good things, whatever we have done a couple of years back or last year. So this journey will continue. And on employees, please understand we have added quite a lot of capability on software, electronics, digital analytics because we have set up this because when we look at future, future is going to be all going to be digitally connected, connected vehicles in the future, not only in EV, you will see that in ICE, you will see in 3-wheeler, you will see it everywhere. So I'm very sure that the growth momentum, these are the key inputs for the future growth. And while we are looking at quarter, we should look at maybe next several years of the company and several years of TVS brand being successful, not only in domestic market, international market, maybe every market in the world.
Question
Pramod Kumar: Sir, on the margin bit?
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: Margin will continue to grow because when the top line is growing, I'm very sure that is going to also fall through into EBITDA journey. It is going into PBT journey. Okay, I don't want to repeat. You look at the absolute, you look at how it is moving. You look at the percentages, everything is in the right direction.
Question
Pramod Kumar: I hear you, sir. And I think this long-term thinking is what got the company here, thanks to the vision of the promoter and you. So congratulations on that stellar journey what you had. My second question is on the capacity side. Then I have one clarification question for Desikan sir, on this financing demerger on the demerger. So on the capacity side, sir, if you can just help us understand because what we understand from the feedback from the market and also you said your inventories are much lower than where they should be ideally. What is the next phase of capacity unlock we'll see? And where are we today on monthly run rate and where the numbers will be, say, by the year-e
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: I think this work will happen now. I think as I told you, we will cross more than 8 million 2- wheeler capacity. And 3-wheeler, we will come to almost 0.4 million, soon. I think these are the areas. And we also said that we will be investing behind that. Definitely, we have to look at capacities for next year because market pull in the market is pretty good. That work will happen Page 13 of 17 TVS Motor Company Limited October 28, 2026 now because many times, some of the capacities require a little longer-range planning.
Question
K. Gopala Desikan: Yes Moderator: The next question is from the line of Kumar Rakesh from BNP Paribas.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: See Norton, I gave you the full explanation. I think the products are getting launched in many markets. The dealerships are getting set up. We are also coming up with certain new models, which some of them will get you will see them in the EICMA next week. So it's a journey, and we are pretty confident the media, the customer feedback, everything has been very positive, both on Manx R and Atlas. And we are pretty confident that this brand is going to definitely be one of the best brands in the super premium category, okay? So I would like to talk about that.
Question
K. Gopala Desikan: Just to on the e-bike again, see, the current quarter loss is lower than the previous quarter loss. That's the first statement. The loss is again because of the brand-related expenses incurred for Norton and the launch-related costs have slightly gone up from the previous reported quarter. It is the reason for...
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: Actually, I would say these are all investments behind Norton. Last year, we started the journey with EICMA and then we had network. We invested behind the launches. We had the media rights, the feedback and also setting up facilities in Solihull, in TVS Motor. And also now it is I told you about many markets in Europe. Now you will see in India. Then after that, we are looking at many markets in U.S. So it's a journey.
Question
Kumar Rakesh: Okay. Just one final question on the investments which you are doing in the Singapore entity in this quarter. Can you just give us some understanding of where that is going? Is it also for entirely Norton?
Answer, k radhakrishnan
K. N. Radhakrishnan: Yes, it is all entirely for Norton. The additional investment, what we said about INR1,200 crores is on TVS Credit Services. Can we have the last question, please?
Question
Viraj Kacharia: Okay. And last question, going into 2028 because now TVS Credit Services, consumer finance different entity altogether, how should we look at the investment spend for TVS Motors going into 2028? Page 16 of 17 TVS Motor Company Limited October 28, 2026 K. N. Radhakrishnan: I think the investments, please understand investment will be predominantly in the area of new product development, if I look at TVS Motor.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
And Norton, I think it is based on the product plan we have to look at what kind of investments we have to do. Otherwise, any new opportunities we will be constantly evaluating and we you know that we have always looked at new product, new technology and also we have always looked at areas where there is an opportunity. So I think that work is going on now. So possibly next quarter, we'll be able to give you some guidelines on '28, '29, what is the likely kind of numbers. Thank you. So before I close, once again, festival greetings and a happy Diwali to all of you. While there were commodity prices increases in Q1 and Q2, we were able to take up some prices.
Answer, k radhakrishnan
We are able to partially mitigate through the cost reduction, also optimization initiatives on product mix. And most importantly, we were able to drive the top line, especially in Q2 a complete portfolio, our unwavering focus on consumers, quality, the new products and the attractive quality technology with features whatever we have given, company is confident about outperforming the industry, both in domestic and international market. And I am pretty confident that going forward, the customer demand for TVS's products are extremely positive and good and both in 2-wheelers, 3-wheelers and many markets in India as well as in abroad. And we are confident that we will continue the momentum on our EBITDA journey going forward. Thank you. Thank you for all the investors and all the analysts for joining today.
Questions about this call
- When was the TVS Motor Company Q2 FY27 earnings call transcript filed?
- TVS Motor Company filed the transcript with the exchange on 4 Nov 2026. This page is built from that transcript.
- What does this page list?
- 38 statements from the transcript across 5 topics, 21 of them with a figure. Each statement is shown with the transcript sentence it came from.
- Are the analysts' questions included?
- Yes. 10 questions and management's answers are listed in the order they were asked, as the transcript prints them.
- Who wrote this page?
- DalalOS Data Desk. Assembled by software from the company's transcript. Not reviewed by a person. How it is made, and what it leaves out, is on the method page linked from the byline.