Earnings call
Balrampur Chini Mills Q3 FY25 earnings call: Balrampur Chini Mills Limited expects its 48-basis-point recovery decline to reduce as the season ends because recovery is picking up
By DalalOS Data Desk. Assembled by software from the company's transcript. Not reviewed by a person.
Transcript filed .
The company expects its 48-basis-point recovery decline to reduce as the season ends because recovery is picking up. The higher investment in Balrampur Chini Mills Limited's PLA project will enhance capacity from 75,000 to 80,000 tons and result in a much lower conversion cost than envisaged. Cane crushing during the third quarter and nine months period ended December 31, 2024 was 10.4% higher than during the same period last year, while sugar recovery remained lower by around 48 bps due to adverse weather conditions. According to latest ISMA estimates, Indian sugar production net of diversion to ethanol is 272 lakh tonnes, down from 320 lakh tonnes, reflecting a 15% decline. The company borrowed around Rs. 325 crore for the PLA project within December, and its existing long-term debt is Rs. 200 crore.
The numbers management gave
Results
- Cane crushing during the third quarter and nine months period ended December 31, 2024 was 10.4% higher than during the same period last year, while sugar recovery remained lower by around 48 bps due to adverse weather conditions.
Show source
Cane crushing during the quarter was up by 10.4%.
- Two of Balrampur Chini Mills Limited's factories have already surpassed last year's recovery on date.
Show source
In fact, in two of our factories, we have already surpassed last year's recovery on date, which is a very encouraging sign.
Money and capital
- Of Balrampur Chini Mills Limited's existing long-term debt of Rs. 200 crore, Rs. 22-odd crore will be repaid within March 2025, followed by Rs. 89 crore payable annually in the next two years.
Show source
Out of this Rs. 200 crore, Rs. 22-odd crore will be repaid within March 2025.
- The company has already spent Rs. 700 crore on the PLA project; around 10% to 15% of the Rs. 2,850 crore project cost will be paid after project commencement.
Show source
So, the Rs. 2,850 crore we will retain, around 10% to 15% that will be paid after the commencement of the project.
- Existing loans are variable, and the cost has come down by 25 basis points on some portion of the loan with the drop in the repo rate.
Show source
Our existing loans are variable, so with the drop in the repo rate, the cost has come down by 25 basis points on some portion of the loan.
- The company will fund the revised capital expenditure for its Poly Lactic Acid (PLA) project through ₹1,650 crores in debt and ₹1,200 crores from internal accruals.
Show source
The project cost is expected to be funded through long-term debt of Rs. 1,650 crore and Rs. 1,200 crore from internal accruals.
Show 2 more statements
Money and capital
- Short-term loan is fully backed by inventory.
Show source
Short term loan is fully backed by inventory.
- The company borrowed around Rs. 325 crore for the PLA project within December, and its existing long-term debt is Rs. 200 crore. Replaced by a later filing.
What it expects ahead
What management expects
- The company expects its 48-basis-point recovery decline to reduce as the season ends because recovery is picking up.
Show source
Our recovery is now picking up, which means that our decline of 48 basis points will reduce as the season ends.
- The company hopes its drop in crushing will not exceed 3%, based on its current figures.
Show source
We hope that our drop in crushing will not be, too early, and should not exceed 3%, based on our current figures.
- The company expects a drop of 0.4% or 0.35%, except for Dalmia, whose recovery is slightly lower than last year; the other companies' recovery is much lower than Balrampur Chini Mills Limited's.
Show source
Therefore, even if we expect a drop of 0.4% or 0.35%, except for Dalmia, whose recovery is slightly lower than last year, the others are much lower than us.
- At full capacity, Balrampur Chini Mills Limited's PLA project is expected to generate ~Rs. 2,000 crore in revenue, with EBITDA margins targeted at 35% plus.
Show source
At full capacity, the project is expected to generate ~Rs. 2,000 crore in revenue, with EBITDA margins, though it's still early, we are targeting 35% plus.
- The company is targeting an actual EBITDA margin of 35%; depreciation and interest after capitalization will be below EBITDA.
Show source
Pramod Patwari: So, this is our actual EBITDA margin which we are targeting, because depreciation and interest post capitalization will be below EBITDA.
- If Balrampur Chini Mills Limited draws completely before commencement of the project, the net interest charge on the PLA account will be 3%.
Show source
Let us assume we draw completely before the commencement of the project, so the net interest charge on the PLA account will be 3%.
Show 3 more statements
What management expects
- The company expects juice production and recovery to show marked improvement in the coming quarters as recovery has picked up.
Show source
Therefore, juice production in the coming quarters will show marked improvement, as will recovery.
- The company does not see a good margin from juice-based ethanol even when taking into consideration the full years of operation, despite lower cane recovery showing an improving trend.
Show source
In spite of that, we do not see a good margin coming out of the juice-based ethanol, even if we take into consideration the full years of operation.
- The company expects distillery margin to be muted in comparison to last year and previous years because raw material cost has continuously increased without an increase in realization, while conversion cost also faces inflationary pressure.
Show source
Distillery margin will surely be muted in comparison to last year for previous years because of the continuous increase in the raw material cost and no increase in the realization.
What it is building and selling
Projects and capacity
- PLA project commissioning schedule remains on track for October 2026. Balrampur Chini Mills expects to begin commissioning its PLA project in October.
Show source
The commissioning schedule remains on track for October 2026.
- The company has 90% of orders in place.
Show source
So, it's an intelligently done exercise with all 90% orders in place.
- The Board had previously approved capex of ₹2000 crores for the PLA Project on 18th February, 2024, based on conceptual planning; revised capex stands at ₹ 2850 gross and ₹ 1750 crores net of expected capital subsidy as announced by the U.P. Government. net capex of ₹ 1,750 crores after an expected capital subsidy of ₹ 1,100 crores as per U.P. Government Scheme.
Show source
Now, based on a complete capex and opex review, our project cost stands at Rs. 2,850 crore gross or Rs. 1,750 crore net, with an expected capital subsidy of around Rs. 1,100 crore.
- The company expects its PLA project's opex to be highly competitive, potentially the lowest, based on plant reconfiguration and the use of its own bagasse.
Show source
Our opex will be highly competitive, and I would even hazard to say it will be the lowest, based on the reconfiguration of our plant and the fact that our bagasse etc., , is all our own.
- The company has reduced power consumption and added equipment to lower opex for its PLA project.
Show source
We have reduced power consumption and added equipments to lower the opex.
- The company says its PLA project's capex per ton will be the lowest by far when benchmarked globally.
Show source
When we benchmark globally, our capex per ton will be the lowest by far.
Show 7 more statements
Projects and capacity
- The higher investment in Balrampur Chini Mills Limited's PLA project will enhance capacity from 75,000 to 80,000 tons and result in a much lower conversion cost than envisaged. Replaced by a later filing.
- PLA project remains on schedule, and the UP government's bioplastic policy further enhances its viability. Replaced by a later filing.
Demand and pricing
- According to latest ISMA estimates, Indian sugar production net of diversion to ethanol is 272 lakh tonnes, down from 320 lakh tonnes, reflecting a 15% decline.
Show source
According to latest ISMA estimates, Indian sugar production net of diversion to ethanol is in the region of 272 lakh tonnes.
- Sugar diversion is expected to be 37.5 lakh tonnes as against 20 lakh tonnes last season.
Show source
Sugar diversion is expected to be at 37.5 lakh tonnes as against 20 lakh tonnes last season.
- With domestic consumption estimated at 280 lakh tonnes and exports of 10 lakh tonnes, closing stock is expected to be around 62 lakh tonnes by the end of the current season, based on total supply of 352 lakh tonnes.
Show source
With domestic consumption estimated at 280 lakh tonnes and export of 10 lakh tonnes, we deduct 290 lakh tonnes from 352 lakh tonnes, the closing stock is expected to be around 62 lakh tonnes by the end of the season.
- The current expected price in UP and in Balrampur Chini Mills Limited's mills is upwards of Rs. 41/kg.
Show source
The current expected price in UP and in our mills are prevailing upwards of Rs. 41/kg.
- Selling 75,000 tonnes does not seem to be a challenge at all.
Show source
So, selling out 75,000 tonnes does not seem to be a challenge at all.
Risks, rules and outside factors
Rules and policy
- The government's approval of 10 lakh tonnes of exports has provided some relief to millers and is helping strengthen domestic sugar prices, which are expected to remain robust going ahead.
Show source
The government's approval of 10 lakh tonnes of exports has provided some relief to the millers.
- Under the bioplastic policy, 50% of ECI (Eligible Capital Investment) is the capital subsidy, which might exclude infrastructure cost and water; the policy also provides a 5% interest subvention and an SGST refund.
Show source
So, 50% of ECI is the capital subsidy, that is called Eligible Capital Investment, which might exclude some things like infrastructure cost, water, etc. There is a 5% interest subvention, which means, assume we borrowed at 8%, we net pay 3%, we get 5% from the government.
- The SGST reimbursement is net and applies for a period of 10 years.
Show source
Page 3 of 13 Avantika Saraogi: A net SGST reimbursement for a period of 10 years.
- The recent decision to keep the ethanol price unchanged, without any hike, was very disappointing.
Show source
However, the recent decision to keep the price unchanged or without any hike has been very disappointing.
What the company said on its earnings call, taken from its own transcript. Not advice.
Questions and answers
Question
Avantika Saraogi: Hi. Thank you so much for the question. I just wanted to sort of bring it a bit into perspective. The capex initially envisaged was for the go-ahead of the project, based on the feasibility study, and was considered a Level 5 capex estimate, which can have a variation of +/-50%. Now, we are at a Class-2 estimate, where the variation should not exceed 10%. Hopefully, there will be no upward variation at all. So, I just want to bring into perspective once engineering happens, once certain local factors are considered into the situation which you cannot consider before, then things do tend to change. We have been able to optimize also more than we ever imagine d we could. So,
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: And just to tell you, we have put in very stringent penalties on the suppliers and that has also added to the cost a bit, but it gives us a lot of safety, in our mind. So, it's on quality and achieving the targeted production so that gives us a lot more safety in our mind undertaking a new venture.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: Yes. So, I thought we have seen the subsidy, but I will clarify. So, 50% of ECI is the capital subsidy, that is called Eligible Capital Investment, which might exclude some things like infrastructure cost, water, etc. There is a 5% interest subvention, which means, assume we borrowed at 8%, we net pay 3%, we get 5% from the government. And there is an SGST refund. Avantika, clarify. Page 3 of 13 Avantika Saraogi: A net SGST reimbursement for a period of 10 years.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: Of course.
Answer, pramod patwari
Pramod Patwari: So, as far as 35% margin is concerned, surely, we have taken into consideration the capital subsidy and the interest submission, but SGST net reimbursement as of now has not been factored into it.
Answer, sanjay maniyal
Sanjay Maniyal: Sure, one thing on the recovery part, 48 basis points lower recovery. So, as you I think mentioned that you are now better with the plant cane. Can we assume that overall, with for the crushing season it will be a 40-basis points kind of a loss? And if I am not wrong, you have mentioned 3% decline in the crushing number or the production number?
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: So, crushing number would be 3% lower – is our estimate. And yes, 0.40% loss in recovery.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: Taking the backdrop of others it is very good.
Answer, sanjay maniyal
Sanjay Maniyal: Right, sir. Just last one on the distillery part. With an almost 7% to 8% increase in SAP last year, we have seen two consecutive years of higher sugarcane costs and lower recovery. Meanwhile, ethanol prices have not increased. What would be the impact on the margin from an ethanol perspective? Earlier, w e were making a pretty good margin of Rs. 7 to Rs. 8 in the juice part. Now, what would the economics look like in this scenario?
Answer, pramod patwari
Pramod Patwari: Yes. So, as far as the ethanol is concerned, as sir was also mentioning, there is a lower recovery from the cane which is now showing an improving trend. In spite of that, we do not see a good margin coming out of the juice-based ethanol, even if we take into consideration the full years of operation. Distillery margin will surely be muted in comparison to last year for previous years because of the continuous increase in the raw material cost and no increase in the realization. In addition to the raw material cost, there is an inflationary pressure also on the conversion cost.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: Okay. But having said that, it will look a lot better than what you are seeing now.
Answer, pramod patwari
Pramod Patwari: Yes. The reason for the loss in this quarter is due to the fact that we had very little feedstock available as of 30th September 2024. This can be validated once you see the presentation, which compares the corresponding numbers from 30th September 2023. There was hardly any stock available to produce ethanol, and very few finished goods of ethanol to sell in the December quarter. Last year, due to production restrictions, we migrated from juice and B to C, and we had some opening stock of B-heavy ethanol, which resulted in profit. This year, however, there was hardly any stock of B-heavy ethanol, so there was no significant sell of B-heavy ethanol in the current quarter. Page 4 of 13 Moderator: The next question is from the line of Vikram Suryavanshi from Phillip Capital India.
Answer, pramod patwari
Pramod Patwari: So, our export quota was around 31,000 tonnes. We have traded our export quota, and we retain our domestic release, so we will be getting the domestic release of this 31,000 tonnes over a period of five months beginning from March, so there is an upside in the domestic.
Question
Vikram Suryavanshi: Okay. So, we have traded for the quantity, but the price is not locked, is that right?
Answer, pramod patwari
Pramod Patwari: No, we have traded our license for quantity. So, we have sold our license at ~Rs. 9 crore or something.
Question
Vikram Suryavanshi: Okay. Understood. And basically, for the outlook on ethanol blending, sir has also given some idea, but what would be our production estimate given I think B-Heavy, and juice route may not be that attractive considering the sugar price increase in the domestic market. So, will it significantly impact the full year volume for distillery? And how is the utilization for even grain to ethanol for us?
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: So, there are three parts to this conversation. One, as you know what has happened that we have said it. So, how we have reacted, we have converted two of our units from B-heavy to C-heavy, immediately, after the zero increase. And post the export, sugar production will become attractive. Two, in our mixture we have five refineries out of our 10 factories. So, refinery is seeing good demand. So, we feel with this conversion we will make more sugar and therefore our blended realization should be very good, having five refineries.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Juice, however, we would continue as we have tendered the juice quantity. B-heavy will convert to C. And in our factories, we have spent the capex, so just assuming next year we are sort of feeling that the economics is for producing more C-heavy, all our 10 plant can produce C-heavy throughout, technically. C or B we can produce everywhere. So, we have fungible capacity going ahead.
Question
Vikram Suryavanshi: So, in case B-heavy we were not able to fulfill quantity, can we convert that into C- heavy, or is there any penalty?
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: No, we had converted. I told you that in two factories we could, we had converted into C-heavy. Vikram Suryavanshi: Okay. I was talking about from OMC side that whatever quantity we have committed.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: No, that will get handled, that's not a problem.
Question
Vikram Suryavanshi: Yes. Was there any inventory loss we have accounted or write-off we have taken for this quarter?
Answer, pawan patwari
So, this is the phenomena every year because in Q3 we get ~40-45 days of crushing, so this cost will, on a full year basis, will come down because next quarter we will have 90 days of crushing.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: We have already reduced our 238 percentage over the last three years considerably. So, our percentage this year for 238 should be something between 10% to 15% in crush. And the recovery drop is not with respect to the varietals exactly, it's more the weather phenomena. I also want to see that last year our recovery was actually much higher than we had envisaged that it would be, so it as very strong. So, if you look at absolute terms, our recovery in comparison to the rest of the state, we are actually very strong.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: So, last year C basis was 11.75%, which in itself was very good. And there has been a drop because of the weather conditions. So, we would still be, let's say, we are assuming 0.40% drop, we would still be at 11.35%, which, from Balrampur's perspective, is looking 0.40% lower, and it is a fact. But from the state's perspective, it might still look very good, except Dalmia. Vikram Suryavanshi: Definitely, sir. We really acknowledge your cane development efforts, and we clearly see your recoveries are much better. Additionally, the whole cane availability is much better than the state we are seeing, as the numbers are coming in.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: Absolutely.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: The fact that we are importing PLA compounding, and that we have budgeted for marketing and development expenses in our project cost, is because our target is to have our facility sold out before we begin. So, there's a lot of work going on all the fronts, technology, marketing, government engagement, etc. Shailesh Kanani: That's quite useful.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: We pride ourselves on being able to run over the capacity, which is rated, so we are thinking that rated is optimal.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: So, by the way, a lot of this business is linked to fermentation, a lot of it. And that we have run the best fomentation business by making ethanol from juice. The single plant in the country which makes not even one bag of sugar. So, just we feel a little more confident, I guess.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: And in fact, actually that is the place that determines your recovery, your conversion cost.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: Yes, energy cost and lots of other things.
Show 10 more questions
Question
Shailesh Kanani: Yes. Sir, just the last question from my side, in terms of capex can you give some indicative numbers about FY26 and FY27, and also the current consol debt in divisions? Page 7 of 13 Pramod Patwari: Yes.
Answer, pramod patwari
So, long term, we borrowed around Rs. 325 crore for the purpose of PLA within December, and our existing long-term debt is Rs. 200 crore. Out of this Rs. 200 crore, Rs. 22-odd crore will be repaid within March 2025. Thereafter, Rs. 89 crore is payable on an annual basis in next two years. Short term loan is fully backed by inventory. The figure as of now is net of cash and cash equivalents it should be around Rs. 1,200 crore to Rs. 1,300 crore.
Question
Shailesh Kanani: And sir, in terms of capex figure for FY26 and FY27, how can we factor that in our models? I do not want the whole project cost, but just for cash flow perspective from FY26 to FY27.
Answer, pramod patwari
Pramod Patwari: I think we have already spent Rs. 700 crore. So, the Rs. 2,850 crore we will retain, around 10% to 15% that will be paid after the commencement of the project. The rest will be just proportionate expenditure, it's difficult to give you a month -wise breakup or a quarter-wise breakup.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: Yes. So, it all depends, but we need coming orders, that probably next quarter we will have a better visibility.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: And it is on milestone achievement also.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: Milestone achievements. As we said, we put in very stringent penalties and payment conditions on the suppliers, internationally.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: Let's assume capacity is going up by 10%, so factor in something there. The rest is to put up machines which can lower your energy cost and lower your chemical cost and your input cost, input material consumption. So, these are complex engineering which we hired the best brains globally and we saw that we could have quite good saving in the all the conversion costs, as I mentioned, chemical cost, energy cost and raw material cost. Based on that, certain reconfigurations were done, and therefore this is the result.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: Ordering has all been done largely, all the big bought outs have been ordered.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: There's no space for it to go up. If anything, it might come down.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: No, let's not say that. So, it's an intelligently done exercise with all 90% orders in place.
Answer, deepak d
Deepak D.: So, it would not be that material, even if some little bit of capex inflation happens.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: Yes, that's all you can say right now. Page 8 of 13 Deepak D.: Okay.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: So, basically, the SUP ban is one of the main kickers for us, because now those products are very easily made with PLA. We are looking at all the applications. And it's not an R&D in the sense that everything is possible, we are just sort of working with multiple people. If you ask me who exactly are we selling to, I do not know, but I am working with 10 people on 10 applications to see which one gives us the highest revenue actually.
Answer, deepak d
Deepak D.: Okay. And literally, if I have to compare, so if I am an end consumer, I would have to look at the cost also, what could be my cost through a PLA pellet versus normal plastic pellets. Are we cost competitive? What I mean to say is, by the time we commercialize this, how will the end consumer view it? Because, ultimately, they would be concerned about the cost, right?
Question
Avantika Saraogi: So, firstly, let's talk about the end consumer first, and let's pick up like a product like let's say water bottles, just because everybody knows what a water bottle is.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: The cap of the water bottle you mean.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: Yes. So, hypothetically, if only the cap of the water bottle is being made from PLA and there's some Rs. 0.50 difference, I do not think that matters to the end consumer. We are very, very conscious of the Indian consumer being price sensitive and we are only targeting those applications wherein the cost is easily borne or absorbed either through the value chain or at the end it is not going to a person who cannot afford it, Rs. 0.50, Rs. 1 here and there. We are looking at those kinds of applications itself. So, not the ones which will hurt the common man. So, that is one thing.
Answer, deepak d
Deepak D.: Just to clarify, I was not asking from the point of view of the end consumer like you and me, but the people who are making it, like the people who are manufacturing the bottles or people who are making the plastic bags.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: Yes. So, similarly, look, everybody puts in a margin when they are doing some work, right. So, we are looking at those where Rs. 0.50, Rs. 1 does not matter, even to the middle person in the value chain, because at the end of the day it's the brand or the end consumer who determines the procurement price, that's number one. Number two, if you are asking me for a straight answer pellet to pellet cost, then PLA cost almost double of normal plastic. Now because of our optimizations and everyt hing, let us see where we get to. But in my opinion, I am not really looking at it being a challenge to be sold at the price that I would like.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: Okay, I just want to provide a few more clarifications. One, if there is an SUP ban, we will be able to compete very well with alternative products, such as paper or glass . We do not need any help there.
Question
Avantika Saraogi: Yes, or metal Vivek Saraogi: Yes, or metal.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Additionally, there are many applications for coatings. Coating is not just changing the game. So, selling out 75,000 tonnes does not seem to be a challenge at all. Page 9 of 13 Avantika Saraogi: So, we envisage also the usage of plastic in India to be around 14 million to 15 million tonnes, out of which nearly I would say 45-odd-percent of that is the SUP.
Question
Look, 75,000 tonnes is not even a drop in that ocean.
Answer, deepak d
Deepak D.: No, that's fine. The addressable market is fairly large, that I understand, and opportunity is also big, and we have a good execution track record. I was just wondering about the volume offtake, but fair, you have answered whatever could be answered at this point of time.
Answer, vivek saraogi
Vivek Saraogi: The coating demand could be huge. Coating means let us say, bagasse tray, so just coating that you cannot imagine how much offtake there is, and that does not change the game.
Answer, deepak d
Deepak D.: Okay. Few questions I had on the financials to Pramod sir. Sir, you mentioned that this 35% EBITDA margin includes the subsidy and interest rate subvention also. But I was just wondering how is that possible from accounting perspective, because all the grant incomes usually fall in other income, which is below EBITDA, so is the interest expense.
Answer, pramod patwari
Pramod Patwari: So, this is our actual EBITDA margin which we are targeting, because depreciation and interest post capitalization will be below EBITDA. Deepak D.: Okay. So, the core EBITDA margin remains at 35%.
Answer, pramod patwari
Pramod Patwari: That's what I am saying. Let us assume we draw completely before the commencement of the project, so the net interest charge on the PLA account will be 3%. Our existing loans are variable, so with the drop in the repo rate, the cost has come down by 25 basis points on some portion of the loan. Is that clear?
Questions about this call
- When was the Balrampur Chini Mills Q3 FY25 earnings call transcript filed?
- Balrampur Chini Mills filed the transcript with the exchange on 13 Feb 2025. This page is built from that transcript.
- What does this page list?
- 34 statements from the transcript across 6 topics, 24 of them with a figure. Each statement is shown with the transcript sentence it came from.
- Are the analysts' questions included?
- Yes. 20 questions and management's answers are listed in the order they were asked, as the transcript prints them.
- Who wrote this page?
- DalalOS Data Desk. Assembled by software from the company's transcript. Not reviewed by a person. How it is made, and what it leaves out, is on the method page linked from the byline.