Skip to content

Earnings call

Balrampur Chini Mills Q4 FY25 earnings call: Balrampur Chini Mills Limited expects to use more Rs. 5-5.5 crore liter of grain ethanol capacity, allowing for shutdown time

By . Assembled by software from the company's transcript. Not reviewed by a person.

Transcript filed .

The company expects to use more Rs. 5-5.5 crore liter of grain ethanol capacity, allowing for shutdown time. 80,000 tonne capacity PLA plant is on track for commissioning by Q3 F Y27, with capex of Rs. 2850 crores (gross) or Rs. 1750 crores net, accounting for a government subsidy of 50%. Crushing was down 1.73% season-on-season and gross recovery dropped by 0.44%, the lowest decline among factories in East UP. The maize-based ethanol price is Rs.71.86 per liter and the juice ethanol price is Rs. 65.61 per liter; there is no basis for paying Rs. 6 per liter higher for maize ethanol.

The numbers management gave

Results

  • Crushing was down 1.73% season-on-season and gross recovery dropped by 0.44%, the lowest decline among factories in East UP.
    Show source
    In fact, our crushing was down only 1.73% season-on-season and gross recovery dropped by 0.44%, which is the lowest decline among factories in East UP.
  • Cane availability reduced by 1.74%, while UP cane declined by around 2.5% on average.
    Show source
    So, while UP cane has declined to the tune of maybe around 2.5% on average, Balrampur's cane availability has only reduced by 1.74%.
  • The company crushed about 12% of 0238 last year and half of that this year.
    Show source
    Avantika Saraogi: Last year, we crushed about 12%.
  • Recovery on 238 was not great, and even healthy 238 recovery was not as good as it used to be.
    Show source
    So 238 recovery was not great is the point that even the healthy 238 recovery was not as good as it used to be.
  • The distillery segment was impacted by the government’s decision not to revise ethanol prices for juice and B-heavy routes despite revision in FRP.
    Show source
    However, the distillery segment, as you know, was impacted by government's decision not to revise the ethanol price for juice and B-heavy routes, despite revision in FRP.
  • The sugar segment delivered a strong performance this quarter, driven by healthy margins. Replaced by a later filing.
    Show source
    The sugar segment delivered a strong performance this quarter, driven by healthy margins.

What it expects ahead

What management expects

  • The company expects to use more Rs. 5-5.5 crore liter of grain ethanol capacity, allowing for shutdown time.
    Show source
    Vivek Saraogi: I would say, because you need some shutdown time, more Rs. 5-5.5 crore liter.
  • Meeting any demand for E30 by 2030 is not possible without the factors discussed, including surplus sugar diversion when there is excess.
    Show source
    Any projection to meet any demand E30 by 2030, not possible without this.
  • A $2.5 assumption for PLA pricing on capacity is not a bad assumption, while historically the price has gone to $4; the outcome will depend on market forces and where the market lands.
    Show source
    So, the point is that $2.5 is not a bad assumption in my opinion, but that is what the 80,000 into 250 is 2000.
  • The factors point toward a return to FRP linkage from next year. Replaced by a later filing.
    Show source
    So all the factors are pointing towards back to FRP linkage from next year.

What it is building and selling

Projects and capacity

  • 80,000 tonne capacity PLA plant is on track for commissioning by Q3 F Y27, with capex of Rs. 2850 crores (gross) or Rs. 1750 crores net, accounting for a government subsidy of 50%.
    Show source
    The 80,000 tonne capacity of our PLA plant is on track for commissioning by Q3 F Y27 with a capex of Rs. 2850 crores (gross) or net figure is Rs. 1750 crores accounting for government subsidy of 50%.
  • PLA facility will produce 100% bio-based PLA using sugar as feed stock and is expected to generate around Rs. 2000 crore annual revenue and, hopefully, EBITDA margin of ~35%.
    Show source
    The facility will produce 100% bio-based PLA using sugar as feed stock and is expected to generate around Rs. 2000 crore annual revenue, and hopefully, since it's the first time we are entering into this business, that's why the word hopefully, EBITDA margin of ~35%.
  • Intention was always to use its maize or rice capacity in the off season, and the capacity is not more than Rs. 6 crore liter.
    Show source
    Pramod Patwari: Sanjay, our intention was always to utilize this maize capacity or the rice capacity in the off season and the capacity is not more than Rs. 6 crore liter.

Demand and pricing

  • The maize-based ethanol price is Rs.71.86 per liter and the juice ethanol price is Rs. 65.61 per liter; there is no basis for paying Rs. 6 per liter higher for maize ethanol.
    Show source
    So even now, if I go back to mathematics for the oil company, the maize-based ethanol is being bought at Rs.71.86 per liter and the juice ethanol is at Rs. 65.61 per liter.
  • India’s consumption of straws alone is 100,000 tonnes of resin, PLA straws have been approved by BIS, and Balrampur Chini Mills Limited’s volume is only 80,000 tons.
    Show source
    So India's consumption of straws alone is 100,000 tonnes of resin and PLA straws have been approved by BIS and this is a very big win, I would say as of last month or so, and it should be gazetted soon and this is sort of a, I just want to show that our volume is only 80,000 tons.

Segments

  • Maize is a balancing factor post juice in Maizapur for Balrampur Chini Mills Limited.
    Show source
    So, maize is equal to balancing factor post juice in Maizapur.

Risks, rules and outside factors

Outside factors

  • The government’s 1 million tonne export quota has contributed to firming sugar prices for Balrampur Chini Mills Limited to around Rs. 41/kg at the current prevailing price.
    Show source
    Government's 1 million tonne export quota has also contributed to firming of sugar price for our company around Rs. 41/kg because of the current prevailing price.
  • Surplus sugar diversion could work in Balrampur Chini Mills Limited’s favor when there is excess.
    Show source
    Surplus sugar diversion, one could not do this when there is no excess, but when there is excess, I think again that will work in our favor.
  • Maize price has not reduced and remains stagnant. Replaced by a later filing.
    Show source
    Two, maize price has not reduced, it remains stagnant.

Rules and policy

  • For the ethanol year 2024-25, the government permitted diversion of sugarcane juice and BH molasses for ethanol production.
    Show source
    However, for 2024-25 ethanol year, while diversion of sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses is permitted, so the restriction on quantum was lifted but there was no price increase given.

Everything else said on the call

What management stressed

  • The company is targeting applications where the impact on the final product price will not hurt consumers, such as bottle caps, while using compostable bioplastic.
    Show source
    Vivek Saraogi: And one more thing, Krishan, is we are targeting applications where the impact on the final price of the product will not hurt.

Other

  • Rs. 40,000 crore has been invested.
    Show source
    Rs. 40,000 crore invested, we have highlighted that.
  • The first policy of Gujarat allowed solar to be sold at Rs. 15 per unit because the capital cost was Rs. 12 crore and PLF was 18%-20%; Balrampur Chini Mills Limited set it up.
    Show source
    So, we also remind everyone that first policy of Gujarat allowed solar to be sold at Rs. 15 per unit because then capital cost was Rs. 12 crore, PLF 18%-20%.

What the company said on its earnings call, taken from its own transcript. Not advice.

Questions and answers

  1. Question

    Shailesh Kanani: Congrats sir, on good set of numbers, given the challenges we have faced during the season. So, my first question is with respect to sugar volumes. How do we see that shaping up for the year FY26, given that inventory levels are higher in spite of a 20% increase in the sugar sacrifice for the year?

    Answer, pramod patwari

    Pramod Patwari: Shailesh, as of 31st of March, we are holding around 7.1 lakh tonnes of sugar and in the month of April, we also produced something. If you take that into account, it will be around 7.5 million tonnes. This entire inventory will be liquidated within November. Thereafter, depending upon the quota allocation, we will have to assume something. But if you see our last 2 years data, we have been in the region of selling around 9.4 lakh tonnes of sugar on an annual basis.

  2. Question

    Shailesh Kanani: Just to add the reason I was asking that the 9.4 lakh tonnes average what we had, we had little bit of a lower side when the inventory was little bit lower side. This time around we have little higher inventory. So, I was just wondering if we can see an uptick on the volume, that way?

    Answer, pramod patwari

    Pramod Patwari: So maybe 10 lakh tonnes is what we can, but this is a guess as of now. Page 3 of 10 Shailesh Kanani: Yes.

  3. Question

    So that is what I was thinking.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: We are hoping for a little higher volume for sure.

  4. Question

    Shailesh Kanani: Yes, absolutely. So my second question was with respect to sugar prices. We have seen a marginal uptake for FY25 broadly in line with our increasing cost of production. And FY26 looks to have started on a promising note with already sugar prices above FY27 average by around Rs. 2 per kg. How do we foresee this average playing out for FY26?

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: So right now, as we have informed you, our price is around Rs.41/kg. I think this is what has been prevailing in this quarter, approximately around this range. So, I would say that this price level should definitely maintain. And the rest would depend on the government's policy for next year. So, if at all, we'll see a marginal uptick in the coming months.

  5. Question

    Shailesh Kanani: That's helpful. Sir, one data point from the PPT, there was a slight year-on-year dip in the transfer pricing of syrup, whereas sugar prices in general have gone up. So what are the rationale behind that sir?

    Answer, pramod patwari

    Pramod Patwari: Last year, the production was restricted on account of that the conversion cost was on a higher side. The loaded conversion cost on the syrup quantity was on a higher side.

  6. Question

    Shailesh Kanani: So, this question is for Avantika ma'am. Ma'am, we have kind of earlier indicated about increasing our catchment area as well, And , in our earlier commentary, we have also said that Eastern UP has better scope in terms of improving the catchment area, vis-à-vis other parts like Western UP. How are we placed over there? If you can throw some light on that aspect of increasing the crushing ?

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: So. I will try and take this question, then Avantika can come in. So if you've seen the honorable Chief Minister's statement of f late, he has said that he would reallocate area from defaulters to good paymasters. So , one definitely remains hopeful on that front. And those areas itself have a lot of scope to develop because they have been belonging to not so good paymasters and therefore the farmer does not develop cane there. On our cane area, we are working hard and Avantika rest on to you.

    Answer, avantika saraogi

    Avantika Saraogi: So our ultimate goal is cane availability right , how much can I crush. S o that is not always dependent on areas. We have actually seen that it depends more on yield than on area in the past 3 years at least I can say that pretty confidently. So even when our area was increasing, the cane was not increasing. But as the area stays a bit stagnant, the yields start to also improve a little bit. So , it's a sort of balancing act. And at the end of the day, our cane availability should remain strong.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: If I am to hazard a guess and please mark my language, it says hazard a guess. Next season probably we will see some uptick and thereafter a very decent uptick.

  7. Question

    Shailesh Kanani: Yes, that is what actually I wanted to understand.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: Okay, I will answer this in two parts. I don't think that messages in that manner, which you said I think there's a statement of saying E30 by 2030, I mentioned that in my opening remarks. So, let's understand what happened this year. To t he best of our knowledge, the OMCs and the Petroleum Ministry got a bit stingy and they wanted to maximize profits. The impact of that will be very severely felt in future if they do not repair the mistake. So even now, if I go back to mathematics for the oil company, the maize-based ethanol is being bought at Rs.71.86 per liter and the juice ethanol is at Rs. 65.61 per liter. So there is no basis of paying Rs. 6 per liter higher for maize ethanol.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    There was a misnomer that the sugarcane is a bigger water guzzler than maize. Now that has ended, that debate has conclusively ended in parliament and with the inter-ministerial committee study. So, we are back on even keel or we are in an advantage against maize on the concept of cultivation. Secondly, this hurt and this pain point has now to the best of our knowledge been understood by the government. So one cannot repair the past, but I think the future remains linkage back to FRP, but too early. But one is definitely over. Avantika, you want to add?

    Answer, avantika saraogi

    Avantika Saraogi: If we just compare agri-based feedstocks for anything, whether it is for ethanol or for SAF or for PLA for that matter, sugarcane remains to be the most environmentally efficient crop, whether it is land use, whether it is water use, whether it is carbon footprint or whether it is even remuneration on a long-term basis to the farmer itself from one same piece of land year -on-year. So there is no denying that. Maybe people might sort of try to move away but ultimately they have to come back because this logic is infallible.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: I think government has understood this concept. The display of the understanding should be evident by next year or when the ethanol price is fixed.

  8. Question

    Sanjay Manyal: In a similar context, you mentioned about the maize ethanol price at Rs. 71.86 per liter. So how is the economics given the fact that maize prices have also come down and probably enough availability of rice? How are the margins in grain ethanol and what are our plans? Because I think we still have fungible capacity to the tune of Rs. 10 crore. Maybe we'll do only Rs. 5 or 6 crore liter. But what is our plan and what are the margins in the grain ethanol?

    Answer, pramod patwari

    Pramod Patwari: Sanjay, our intention was always to utilize this maize capacity or the rice capacity in the off season and the capacity is not more than Rs. 6 crore liter. If we have full availability of molasses or B-heavy molasses or juices available.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: I would say, because you need some shutdown time, more Rs. 5-5.5 crore liter. So, maize is equal to balancing factor post juice in Maizapur. We have one single capacity. Two, maize price has not reduced, it remains stagnant. What I did is give a comparative between what the OMC buys maize ethanol at and juice ethanol at. That is what I did. Just to sort of drill down the logic that if one is looking at profitability for OMC, even on that front, now we stand out very conclusively, water we stand out conclusively.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Any projection to meet any demand E30 by 2030, not possible without this. Rs. 40,000 crore invested, we have highlighted that. Surplus sugar diversion, one could not do this when there is no excess, but when there is excess, I think again that will work in our favor. So all the factors are the OMC buys maize ethanol at and juice ethanol at. That is what I did. Just to sort of drill down the logic that if one is looking at profitability for OMC, even on that front, now we stand out very conclusively, water we stand out conclusively. Any projection to meet any demand E30 by 2030, not possible without this.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Rs. 40,000 crore invested, we have highlighted that. Surplus sugar diversion, one could not do this when there is no excess, but when there is excess, I think again that will work in our favor. So all the factors are pointing towards back to FRP linkage from next year. Page 5 of 10 Sanjay Manyal: And sir if you can just quantify, is it possible to quantify grain ethanol margin either from the maize or the broken rice?

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: So we don't do broken rice because maize is better. Pramod?

    Answer, pramod patwari

    Pramod Patwari: Sanjay, it will vary on a company to company basis. Our intent is to utilize our capacity.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: Pramod, this year maize as raw material has been better available and lower price. We will definitely make money.

    Answer, pramod patwari

    Pramod Patwari: But it cannot be compared with a person who is in full year maize capacity, who is utilizing this capacity on a full year basis on maize.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: But Pramod, I would differ a bit, but we have our own energy source which they don't. So we are far more efficient there.

  9. Question

    Sanjay Manyal: Perfect. So just one more question on the recovery part. I think, so is it that entire industry, specifically in UP is witnessing this lower recovery because they are now shifting from Co-0238 to newer varieties? So safe to assume that we are nowhere near Co-0238 neither in terms of sugarcane yield or recovery?

    Answer, avantika saraogi

    Avantika Saraogi: No, no, no. I think this is not the right way to look at it. In my opinion, it's a sort of a temporary phase when there is a shift happening as you know or maybe you don't know, but acclimatization of any new variety in any new place takes a little bit of longer time. There is no single variety released by the sugarcane institute until and unless it is not performing in terms of yield and recovery as much as 238. That is the new benchmark. So, in terms of potential, they all can have that thing but if I remind you even for Balrampur, it took us about 5 to 6 years to get everything from 238 which we started to get. I think it was back in 2019 or something like that. So the thing is that it takes some time.

    Answer, avantika saraogi

    The sad part about sugarcane is that it's a one-year crop. So, everything takes longer to come to fruition. But this is not the right thought process at all. The future looks very good because the research and the varieties which are coming out, actually have very good potential and that too for more varied circumstances as well.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: So if I may just add to that, if you see two of our plants in Kheri district, they almost had last year's recovery. So we suffered not because of variety, we suffered because of severe rains in October. Avantika Saraogi: And also agro-climatic conditions, sometimes it rains too much. Like I think we mentioned this in the past, is that how it rains and when it rains. So last 2 years in fact, which I would like to give the good news right now is that from October until June, we did not see a drop of rain last time. This year already in May, it has rained. April, May combined it has rained three times.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: It looks better than last year crop condition. If it does not flood in September, October, we should see much better recovery.

    Answer, avantika saraogi

    Avantika Saraogi: So it's more agro-climatic, otherwise a full state cannot just go down like this.

  10. Question

    We have given of course an estimation on the EBITDA that we're looking at, we've also given an estimated timeline and an estimated topline. Could you give us how much is the estimated cane which will be required to for this capacity to run which is an optimal capacity of 80,000 tons per annum?

    Answer, avantika saraogi

    Avantika Saraogi: So actually it's not sugarcane which is the main feedstock, it's sugar. It will get linked to that only. It will get linked to, but it depends on recovery, how can I say sugarcane, right? So, sugar is basically we have said around 1.7x of 80,000 tonnes which is around 1.25 lakh tonnes.

    Answer, pramod patwari

    Pramod Patwari: This year we diverted 2 lakh tonnes of sugar towards Ethanol. Vivek Saraogi: Okay. So you can, I think I like what Pramod has said. If this year we diverted 2 lakh tonnes of sugar and assume we were doing this PLA business this year, we have diverted 3.25 lakh tonnes. Extra diversion of 1.25 lakh tonnes of sugar towards PLA. Avantika Saraogi: Yes, so you can look at it as how much less sugar in circulation rather than sugarcane. That's the easier way to look at it.

Show 5 more questions
  1. Question

    Nitin Awasthi: No, so basically the gap between FRP and SAP used to be quite substantial compared to the new FRP announcement which has happened?

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: No, so you can't plot trends like this. But our honorable Chief Minister is an extremely practical person. But one does not believe SAP to remain constant. So you cannot derive a mathematical relationship if that's what you're looking at. But yes, sugarcane price in UP is declared with a far more practical mindset of our Honorable CM. Nitin Awasthi: Understood sir.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: So 2 questions. One is FRP linkage will have nothing to do with maize price. That is just the ability to raise ethanol price looking at 2 sources of ethanol was my communication. And East UP has a minimum red rot in the state, minimum. And for us, Avantika, how much do we have left?

    Answer, avantika saraogi

    Avantika Saraogi: Which we can easily monitor and almost baby. Red rot is a thing of the past for us, for Balrampur. Dhvaneet Savla: Okay. My question on the FRP was not based on the FRP but based on the price revision which if we are looking at anything, it should be above what the maize -based ethanol is, right?

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: So that is what logic demands. You are totally correct that is what logic demands. That is what past precedent demands. I am not sure it is going to go up that fast, that soon, but yes, at least to the extent of FRP raise this year, one is definitely hopeful.

  2. Question

    Dhvaneet Savla: So, somewhere in the range of 10%?

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: I'm not fixing them, too early but yes positively inclined towards the FRP percentage increase levels.

    Answer, pramod patwari

    Pramod Patwari: I am sure you are aware of the fact that last year there was a restriction on production of ethanol out of juice and B-heavy. As a result of which, our capacities were underutilized in FY25. Ethanol year runs from November to October. Initial part of the year, we were able to run our distillery on juice and B. Thereafter it was restricted. Disha: Okay. What are the economies to decide to run ethanol on C-heavy basis and if you can just advise on margin percentage on maize or how do we decide?

    Answer, pramod patwari

    Pramod Patwari: These are clearly stated in our presentation in a very detailed manner and every year’s planning depends on the availability of sugarcane, what is the potential export price, what is the potential ethanol price. Disha: What is the quantum of cane crush we are planning for FY26, next year, next season?

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: So, we don't plan for cane crushes on availability of cane. Too early, I did indicate that there might be a marginal uptake beyond which there is no guess I can make today.

    Answer, avantika saraogi

    Avantika Saraogi: So that's a good question actually. It's hard to sort of predict one and a half years out what the prices will be, but it comes to a $2.5 only on capacity. But this is of course going to depend on the market forces and where we land. And historically it's even gone to $4. So, what is to say it can't go to $4? So, the point is that $2.5 is not a bad assumption in my opinion, but that is what the 80,000 into 250 is 2000. So that is what we try to predict.

  3. Question

    Krishan Parwani: Yes, got it. I mean, yes, it could be disposable tableware or extruded blister Vivek Saraogi: Yes, even bottles, even bottle caps.

    Answer, avantika saraogi

    Avantika Saraogi: No. It's not required for food grade. Food grade certification is required for food grade like FSSAI and things like that in our country. Post that USFDA might be required for the compound or the converter who is then finally making the product. For us, the food grade, in fact, the compostability and FSSAI approvals are already well underway. So, it doesn't affect us directly those things. I also wanted to put in an interesting metric since you're talking about PLA and its applications. So India's consumption of straws alone is 100,000 tonnes of resin and PLA straws have been approved by BIS and this is a very big win, I would say as of last month or so, and it should be gazetted soon and this is sort of a, I just want to show that our volume is only 80,000 tons.

  4. Question

    Krishan Parwani: Fair point.

    Answer, vivek saraogi

    Vivek Saraogi: And one more thing, Krishan, is we are targeting applications where the impact on the final price of the product will not hurt. So, let's say a cap for a bottle that's going to go into sort of negligible territory. It's not going to hurt. So we are targeting those Page 9 of 10 applications where the consumer will not feel anything plus there would be that compostable bioplastic in play. So, we also remind everyone that first policy of Gujarat allowed solar to be sold at Rs. 15 per unit because then capital cost was Rs. 12 crore, PLF 18%-20%. We set it up. So I know it.

  5. Question

    Shailesh Kanani: Just a couple of data-keeping questions. In general, what are we seeing in terms of ethanol volumes for the FY26? And second, Avantika ma'am said that our dependence on 0238 is 6%. I believe that was somewhere in the range of 25% odd. So it is substantially down, so I've heard it right.

    Answer, avantika saraogi

    Avantika Saraogi: Last year, we crushed about 12%. This year we crushed half of that. The recovery is on the 238. So, we do mid-season analysis on a sort of weekly basis on varietal performance. So 238 recovery was not great is the point that even the healthy 238 recovery was not as good as it used to be. It was okay. But other varieties were also performing that well.

Questions about this call

When was the Balrampur Chini Mills Q4 FY25 earnings call transcript filed?
Balrampur Chini Mills filed the transcript with the exchange on 21 May 2025. This page is built from that transcript.
What does this page list?
23 statements from the transcript across 9 topics, 16 of them with a figure. Each statement is shown with the transcript sentence it came from.
Are the analysts' questions included?
Yes. 15 questions and management's answers are listed in the order they were asked, as the transcript prints them.
Who wrote this page?
DalalOS Data Desk. Assembled by software from the company's transcript. Not reviewed by a person. How it is made, and what it leaves out, is on the method page linked from the byline.
Research and analysis only, not investment advice. Every statement on this page is the company's own, taken from its transcript; DalalOS adds no view on it and is not a SEBI-registered investment adviser. Something wrong? Report an error.
Balrampur Chini Mills Q4 FY25 concall: Balrampur Chini Mills Limited expects to use more Rs. 5-5.5 crore liter of grain ethanol capacity, allowing for shutdown time · DalalOS