Earnings call
Acme Solar Holdings Q2 FY25 earnings call: Acme Solar Holdings Limited's 1,200 megawatts of projects won are a combination of hybrids, solar and FDRE projects
By DalalOS Data Desk. Assembled by software from the company's transcript. Not reviewed by a person.
Transcript filed .
1,200 megawatts of projects won are a combination of hybrids, solar and FDRE projects. The company said it could not estimate capex 2.5 years down the line for some PPAs, including a SECI PPA that allows it to take connectivity for 2027; that plan needs to get live around 2027. The company had not capitalized 1,200 megawatts because capitalization happens on full commissioning of the plant, when it receives the COD certificate. The company said it typically generated revenue of around INR1.5 crores per day and had achieved EBITDA margins at the asset level of 92%, 93%; when fully operational, this plant would generate substantially more than INR1.5 crores per day. FDRE project tariffs are in the range of 4.4 to 4.7.
The numbers management gave
Results
- The company said it typically generated revenue of around INR1.5 crores per day and had achieved EBITDA margins at the asset level of 92%, 93%; when fully operational, this plant would generate substantially more than INR1.5 crores per day.
Show source
So, in terms of the EBITDA margins at the asset level, we have done 92%, 93% in terms of the EBITDA margins.
- The tariff for Acme Solar Holdings Limited's plant was roughly INR2.44 per unit, and the expected AC CUF for the plant was 30%.
Show source
And we have disclosed in the prospectus, the tariff for this plant is roughly INR2.44 per unit.
- The company said seasonality causes around 10% revenue difference quarter-on-quarter, and the second quarter is affected by monsoon; it expected no impact from this weather in the next two quarters.
Show source
So, you will see around, I think, 10% sort of revenue difference coming from seasonality.
- CUF for its first quarter increased from 23.3% in FY24 to 24.6% in FY25 because of operational improvements such as robotic cleaning; its capacity utilization factor increased from 23.3% in H1FY24 to 24.6% in H1FY25 owing to initiatives focused on preventive and predictive maintenance.
Show source
Manoj Upadhyay: The first quarter, our first quarter, if you compare the ‘24 versus ‘25, FY25 quarter, our CUF has gone up from 23.3% to 24.6%.
- The company receives 75% of the tariff during pre-commissioning and 100% of the tariff after commissioning.
Show source
And post that, pre-commissioning, you get 75% of the tariff also.
- The company said revenue is a function of units, as new plants are coming at lower tariffs.
Show source
Page 12 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 Nikhil Dhingra: So, it's a function of, see, revenue is a function of units, because as the new plants are coming, they are coming at lower tariffs, right?
Show 15 more statements
Results
- The company has been able to recognize revenue since October.
Show source
So, in terms of the revenue, we are able to recognize the revenue since October.
- The company has been generating and selling power to either the off-taker or the merchant.
Show source
We have been generating and selling power to either the off-taker or to the merchant.
- Higher-than-expected rainfall in the Gujarat area affected solar generation in the last quarter.
Show source
I think also in this business, you must have seen that, in fact, last quarter, especially in the Gujarat area, it has been rained more than what we have expected.
Money and capital
- The company had capitalized around INR5,400 crores in the books, including a provision for MOOWR of around INR1,400 crores that it had not yet spent as a buffer; adjusted for that provision, the amount was around 4,000 crores, with INR200 crores of payments still to make, and actual cash spent for this plant could be taken at a maximum of around INR4,200 crores to INR4,400 crores.
Show source
So, maybe somewhere around INR4,200 crores to INR4,400 crores is the actual cash spent you can take at maximum for this plant.
- The company expects an 8.7 rate at AA for a plant operational for more than 5 years that is a group of NTPC, SECI.
Show source
Nikhil Dhingra: So, 8.7 will be the rate which will be at AA.
- The company expects refinancing to extend loan tenor and reduce interest rates, with improved project ratings helping to lower borrowing costs.
Show source
And second is to reduce the interest rate because the lender changes -- the rating of the project also improves.
- The company is targeting a AA rating for one project, which it expected to know in a day or two.
Show source
Like in one of the projects we are targeting to take a AA rating, which will be known in a day or two to us.
- The company expects equity raised in its holding company to contribute to rating improvements at the restricted group or wherever it borrows.
Show source
And as we have raised equity in our holding company, so we are expecting this to happen more in terms of the improvement in rating at the restricted group or wherever we borrow.
- All three refinancings achieved the purpose of providing Acme Solar Holdings Limited with debt release for growth.
Show source
And all three have achieved this purpose of giving us, you can say, debt release for growth.
- The company does not want to monetize its assets for now and wants to consolidate them; it may evaluate an InvIT in the future, subject to whether listing makes sense for shareholders.
Show source
In terms of monetization, we don't want to monetize the assets as of now in terms of going forward.
- The company has used monetization in the past because it received good value, raised resources for capex and obtained the lowest cost of equity while keeping the corporate structure intact.
Show source
Because in terms of our equity requirements, so monetization has been the tool which we have used in the past.
- The company has not yet decided whether to pursue an InvIT or asset sale; if comparing the options today, it considers an InvIT better than an asset sale.
Show source
If at all we want to go there, we have not yet decided at all to do InvIT or asset sale.
- The company has no plan to do an InvIT as of now and has no timeline for it.
Show source
So, it's something we have no plan of doing as of now.
- The company sees no compulsion or driver to attempt an InvIT, as it sees no challenge in working with its lenders and getting refinancings done.
Show source
So, as of now, there are no compulsions or no drivers for us to attempt an InvIT.
- Selling assets has a capital gain implication. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
And of course, there is a capital gain implication when you sell assets.
What it expects ahead
What management expects
- The company said it could not estimate capex 2.5 years down the line for some PPAs, including a SECI PPA that allows it to take connectivity for 2027; that plan needs to get live around 2027.
Show source
Nikhil Dhingra: And we don't want to hazard a guess about the capex 2.5 years down the line because some of the PPAs, like you mentioned, there is a SECI PPA, which allows you to take connectivity for 2027.
- The company expects to conclude most of its PPAs in the next few weeks or 1 or 2 months.
Show source
Hopefully, as Nikhil was sharing, we should be able to conclude most of the PPAs in the next few weeks or 1 or 2 months.
- Some Acme Solar Holdings Limited PPAs expected to happen in October might happen this month or next, with elections delaying progress when approval processes are stopped.
Show source
I think some of the PPAs, we thought that should have happened in October, which might happen in this month or in next.
Orders
- 1,200 megawatts of projects won are a combination of hybrids, solar and FDRE projects.
Show source
In terms of the 1,200 megawatts, which we have won, of course, it's a combination of hybrids, solar and FDRE projects.
- The company recently won a tariff of 4.7 with the NTPC bid.
Show source
And we also won a tariff of 4.7 recently with the NTPC bid.
What it is building and selling
Projects and capacity
- The company had not capitalized 1,200 megawatts because capitalization happens on full commissioning of the plant, when it receives the COD certificate.
Show source
So, you're right, Murtaza, that 1,200 megawatts is not yet capitalized because it happens on the full commissioning of the plant, because when you get the COD certificate.
- Overall capex would be roughly around INR40,000 crores-odd.
Show source
But what we can tell you is the overall, in terms of the capex, roughly around, I think, INR40,000 crores-odd will be the overall capex.
- The company said the overall capex for its additional 4 gigawatts, after 2.5 gigawatts is already operational, would be between 40 to 42,000 crore, funded 75% by debt and the balance by equity.
Show source
So to fund additional 4 gigawatts, which we have shown, roughly we need Page 10 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 a capex of somewhere between 40 to 42,000 crore, which will be funded by 75% by debt and balanced by equity.
- The company is timing some projects for 2027-28 because some PPAs allow flexibility; some projects will be built after the 2026 cash flow when the plant becomes operational, and it is staggering some projects.
Show source
Some of the projects we are timing for 2027-28 because some of the PPAs where we had a flexibility.
- The company said its current capex estimate could go up or down and it takes a contingency of around 8% to 10% on capex; given the bias on the cost side, capex will go down.
Show source
From our side, what we do is we take a contingency on the capex side, which is around 8% to 10%.
- The company added around 50 megawatt of capacity at its Aklera project in this half year.
Show source
50 megawatt or so, which was capacity which came up in this half year, in this so, that addition of capacity also happened.
Show 20 more statements
Projects and capacity
- The company targeted to complete the commissioning procedure on 27th, 28th; commissioning would follow the trial run and other conditions falling into place.
Show source
We are targeting to get it done on 27th, 28th.
- Commissioning was expected in the next 10 days or so.
Show source
But in terms of the commissioning, this is expected in the next 10 days or so.
- 1,200 megawatt project comprises four projects, and synchronizing the plants took longer than expected because it was a very large plant and perhaps the first time in India that four plants were synchronized together.
Show source
So, the normal synchronization of the plant took more than what we thought of.
- CWIP moved in the six months because it executed this plant, the Bikaner plant and the wind plant.
Show source
So it has moved because we have executed this plant and we have also executed the Bikaner plant and also the wind plant.
- Gross block had not moved because it had not capitalized so far.
Show source
And, of course, the gross block has not moved because we have not capitalized so far.
- The company said the estimated capex for its projects remains in a similar range and capex is on a downswing, but it could not provide the exact capex number; the remaining capex is basically on the solar side.
Show source
So, all these are, of course, the estimates remain in the similar range and the capex is on a downswing.
- The company had recently capitalized ISTS.
Show source
I think we have already capitalized ISTS recently.
- The company will capitalize the wind plant soon.
Show source
Of course, the wind plant also we will capitalize soon.
- The company said there was an improvement on the capex side for the wind plant.
Show source
I think there is an improvement there on the capex side.
- First time charging had happened for all four plants, allowing it to sell power to the PPA purchaser or, if the purchaser gives NOC, in the merchant market; the plants were undergoing the commissioning procedure.
Show source
So, our first time charging has happened of all four plants.
- Four plants were synchronized together, which took longer because it was a very large plant and perhaps the first time in India that four plants were synchronized together. Replaced by a later filing.
Demand and pricing
- FDRE project tariffs are in the range of 4.4 to 4.7.
Show source
These are plain solar bids you are looking at, but when you look at the FDRE projects, the tariffs are in the range of between 4.4 to 4.7 sort of range.
- Hybrid tariffs are 3.3 to 3.4, 3.25 now.
Show source
And when you look at hybrid, these are in the three handles in terms of 3.3 to 3.4, 3.25 now.
- INR2.51 is a good tariff because capex has come down to that level.
Show source
It is because the capex has come down to the level that it is actually a good tariff.
- The company sold power to the grid at a higher price than it would have received under the PPA.
Show source
So, fortunately, we are selling the power to the grid at a higher price than it would have been in the PPA.
- The company does not target a specific tariff. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
So, we don't target a specific tariff.
- FDRE projects offer an opportunity for high returns but also involve risk, and have slightly fewer competitors than plain solar bids because of project complexity. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
So, that is why you see in an FDRE project, there are slightly less competitors as compared to a plain solar bid, purely because of the degree of complication in the project.
- Plain battery projects are slightly simpler, and plain battery tenders have a lot of competition. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
And of course, a plain battery is slightly simpler, so you will see a lot of competition in the plain battery tenders also.
Segments
- The company targets a hurdle rate based on FCFE IRR, cash flows over 25 years and cost savings achievable through its EPC; it does not include refinancing-rate or top-up upsides in bids and keeps around 10% contingency in estimated capex.
Show source
We target a hurdle rate, which is FCFE, IRR, taking the cash flows of the 25 years and also you can say, the cost saving we can achieve through our EPC.
- High FDRE projects involve solar, wind, and battery technologies, with elements slightly higher than plain solar. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
And when you're looking at a high FDRE, there are elements that are slightly higher than a plain solar because you are dealing in three technologies, solar, wind, and battery.
Risks, rules and outside factors
Outside factors
- The company said per megawatt cost would be roughly around the same for Indian modules versus Chinese modules, adjusted for the duty difference.
Show source
Of course, there is a duty difference, right, so, adjusted for that, Indian modules are roughly in the same range.
- Tariff depends on capex and macroeconomic variables including interest rates and dollar rates, as some capex is imported.
Show source
And, of course, a lot of macroeconomic variables like interest rates and dollar rates because some of the capex is imported and various other things are there in terms of the interest rate because the capex heavy business model.
- Projects can buy cells from China.
Show source
And of course, in all our projects, we can buy cells from China.
- Solar module capex is on a downturn, as Acme Solar Holdings Limited re-emphasized.
Show source
And the capex is on a downturn as we are re-emphasizing.
Rules and policy
- Because of a change in the laws, Acme Solar Holdings Limited needs to take revenue from power generation to the P&L rather than reduce it from project cost.
Show source
But now, because of the change in the laws, we need to take this to the P&L. Gopal: Okay, sure sir.
Everything else said on the call
What management stressed
- Integrated business model helps it control time and cost and achieve its targeted hurdle rates. Replaced by a later filing.
Show source
And, of course, these hurdle rates we have, of course, an integrated business model which helps us control time and cost.
What the company said on its earnings call, taken from its own transcript. Not advice.
Questions and answers
Question
Anupam Goswami: Hello, sir. My first question is on the commissioning expected in the next, let's say, in the next one year or two years, and with the IPO proceeds, what is the max capacity that we can commission? And beyond that, if we bid and commission, do we need extra proceeds or extra sort of financing from that? That's all, sir.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: Sure. Thanks, Anupam, for your query. So, in terms of the commissioning expected in the next couple of years, right, so, of course, we have around 4.2 gigawatt of capacity, which is under construction, right? And in this business, the commissioning deadline is coming from the date of the substation connectivity, because you can energize your plant, but you can only evacuate your power once the substation is there. So, if you look at all the places, because our connectivity is 100% tied up, so, if you look at the dates of all these connectivities, are coming in before 2027, so, in the financial year 2027. So, all our capex is aligned to that, that all these, let's say, some substations are coming online next year. You can say around 900 megawatt-odd is coming online in the next financial year.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
So, of course, we take a timeline of around two years from the PPA signing as our expected SCOD, but we Page 6 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 make efforts to charge the plant earlier, where the connectivity is already live or expected to be live sooner than that PPA timeline. So, our whole of this 4.2 gigawatt is expected to be charged before around 2027. Of course, if there is a delay in terms of PPA signing, that will be proportionately expended, but that need not necessarily lead to a delay, because if the connectivity is live, we can very well do the plant before SCOD. If you look at even the latest plant which we have charged, our scheduled COD was March 25, but we have made it live in, let's say, as you can see, starting from October, November, it is now live. So, it is possible to do it earlier, but, of course, you are constrained by the connectivity. If the connectivity is live, there is possibility to do it earlier. In terms of the capex sufficiency, as we said, there are three sources of capex.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
So, of course, one is the equity which we have raised from IPO, and, of course, then there is a second source is we are operational cash flows from the operating assets, and the third is the saving you do from the EPC in-house integrated nature. Of course, the operational cash flows from power sale translates, you can expedite them by doing a refinancing. If you look at even this quarter, we have demonstrated all these three sources. We had construction EPC of around INR198 odd crores in this half financial year, and then we had around, we have shown you the cash flows coming from refinancing, which are, again, in the nature of, I think, once all three refinancings are done, they will be in the nature of INR400, INR500 crores. So, these are the three sources which will help us reach these capex plans which we are seeing. And, of course, we will not need to dilute as per our estimates because there are a lot of capex upsides which are possible and which currently seem possible in terms of the capex which is required to set up an FDRE plant or an hybrid plant. As you must have gathered from other companies which are also operating in the sector and who have also won FDRE and battery- related tenders, the capex is on a downturn in terms of the battery cost, in terms of the various associated costs.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
So, as per the current capex estimates, we don't need, we don't think that we will need to raise equity. Of course, as we right-size the capital structure, as we see, because we are new to the listed space. So, we can always evaluate in terms of, let's say, if the market is stagnant in terms of the tariffs because we target mid- teen returns when we bid for a new project. So, if the mid- teen returns are not available, we may slow our growth, of course, and at that time, we can reduce our debt from our internal cash flows and that is how we will size up the market in terms of whether and, of course, as you know, cost of equity is higher than cost of debt, but we will always try to strike a balance in terms of sustainable debt-to-EBITDA and we will try to temper our growth and calibrate our growth such that we get their mid- teen returns and we also honor the sustainable debt-to-EBITDA numbers which we have targeted.
Answer, manoj upadhyay
Manoj Upadhyay: I would like to add here, Anupam, that we have, for example, we energized 1,200 megawatts in October. Another 450 megawatts is getting added in the quarter, right, quarter one of this. So, that's one addition and then what Nikhil suggested that we will wait for another 900 megawatts if that connectivity becomes alive. We will try to do that early commissioning. That is our plan. Page 7 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 Anupam Goswami: Okay, sir.
Question
So, you mentioned about substation and connectivity. Do you see on ground any delay in that?
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: See, the good thing is that most of our connectivity is brownfield wherein we are not dependent on the HVDC connectivity which requires, you can say, a Greenfield capex and land acquisition. So, of course, there could be a quarter delay in even the brownfield capex, but you are able to track that because most of these contracts are given to, of course, Power Grid is the primary execution agency, but there are a lot of good private agencies which are also doing it. So, we don't see a delay in terms of a large delay. A quarter delay is definitely possible in any of these infrastructure projects which Power Grid also is an infrastructure project, whatever they execute, but in bulk of the places where we are doing connectivity, it's more of an equipment rollout or a transmission link strengthening which generally doesn't get delayed. So, we don't see a delay and, of course, we budget. We always time our capex as per the connectivity and as per the, you can say, the PPA timelines. So, we will never try to, let's say, order substantial capex prior to clarity on that and also, because of that, we don't increase our expenses because of the delay.
Question
Abhishek Nigam: Yes. Hi. Thank you so much for the opportunity. So, just three questions. One, I was looking at some of the FDRE projects that we had that were awarded in, I think, January and February. So, do we have PPAs for those now? And, you know, it's been a while. So, if you could update us over there what's happening. So, that's my first question.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: Sure. Sure, Abhishek. So, in terms of the FDRE projects where we have signed PPA, one is the SJVN. Where we had 570 megawatts from SJVN. So, all of that, the PPA has been signed, the tariff has been adopted. So, that is one FDRE which is fully signed. Then we had SECI 380 megawatts which we won.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Again, that was last year. So, for that, 190 megawatt of PPA has been signed and 190 megawatt is still pending. And then we got a SECI 350 megawatt solar plus battery. It doesn't have wind, at 3.42. There also 150 megawatt of PPA has been signed but 200 is pending. There was a large NHPC bid which we won which is 680 megawatts. So, there the NHPC is talking to various states.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
And, of course, there are very advanced stages as per NHPC of getting consent from a state which is expected very shortly. So, as per NHPC, that should happen in a month or so. And this 190 megawatt of SECI, also as per SECI, it should happen quickly. Plus the 200 megawatt which is remaining from 350. These, of course, these decisions are sometimes pending due to various state specific decision making. And so, this is pending and whatever I mentioned is done. Page 8 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 Abhishek Nigam: Okay, fair enough.
Question
Murtuza Arsiwalla: Yes. Hi, sir. A couple of questions. One, in your presentation, there is a breakup between gross block and CWIP, which is largely unchanged. I'm assuming that 1,200 megawatts is still not capitalized. So, that's a clarification. And second, for the projects that you won, 1,350 megawatts, could you also give us a sense of what the costs against those projects are? What is the anticipated cost on an aggregate basis? What is for the remaining sort of 4,000 megawatts? What is the balance sort of capex to be spent?
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: Right. So, you're right, Murtaza, that 1,200 megawatts is not yet capitalized because it happens on the full commissioning of the plant, because when you get the COD certificate. And right now, of course, we are selling power pre-commissioning, of course. So, it is not yet capitalized. And, of course, the CWIP has moved in the six months. So it has moved because we have executed this plant and we have also executed the Bikaner plant and also the wind plant. So, CWIP has moved in the last six months.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
And, of course, the gross block has not moved because we have not capitalized so far. In terms of the 1,200 megawatts, which we have won, of course, it's a combination of hybrids, solar and FDRE projects. So, all these are, of course, the estimates remain in the similar range and the capex is on a downswing. We will not be able to give the exact number of the capex, but it is basically – it is remaining on the solar side. I think we have already capitalized ISTS recently. So, you will see the – in terms of per megawatt cost, of course, it will be roughly around the same or maybe subject to the Indian modules versus the Chinese modules. Of course, there is a duty difference, right, so, adjusted for that, Indian modules are roughly in the same range.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Of course, the wind plant also we will capitalize soon. So, wind also remains. I think there is an improvement there on the capex side. But what we can tell you is the overall, in terms of the capex, roughly around, I think, INR40,000 crores-odd will be the overall capex. Ankit, do you want to add on that?
Answer, ankit verma
Ankit Verma: Yes. So, to fund this entire pipeline Murtuza, which is, like we have mentioned, 2.5 gigawatts is already operational. So to fund additional 4 gigawatts, which we have shown, roughly we need Page 10 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 a capex of somewhere between 40 to 42,000 crore, which will be funded by 75% by debt and balanced by equity.
Answer, manoj upadhyay
Manoj Upadhyay: I think it is also important to mention here, which Nikhil was explaining. Some of the projects we are timing for 2027-28 because some of the PPAs where we had a flexibility. So, what will happen, some of the projects will get built after having the 2026 cash flow when the plant will become operational. So when you see from today's planning, we can't plan that right now because we are staggering some of those projects.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: And we don't want to hazard a guess about the capex 2.5 years down the line because some of the PPAs, like you mentioned, there is a SECI PPA, which allows you to take connectivity for 2027. So, that plan needs to get live around 2027. So, that is too far as for us. So, we can, of course, give you the capex estimate. This is the current cost, but it can go up or down. From our side, what we do is we take a contingency on the capex side, which is around 8% to 10%. And, of course, given the bias on the cost side, it will go down.
Question
Murtuza Arsiwalla: Thank you.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: Right. So, as of now, I think in terms of the books, we have capitalized at around INR5,400 crores. But it includes a provision for the MOOWR, which is very substantial. So, adjusted for that, that is around INR1,400 crores of provision, which we have not yet spent, because that is like a buffer, which is there. So, adjusted for that is around 4,000 crores. So, there is some bit of, I think, payments we need to make INR200 crores. So, maybe somewhere around INR4,200 crores to INR4,400 crores is the actual cash spent you can take at maximum for this plant.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: So, that is something I think you will see in a month or so. Basically, typically revenue we are doing around INR1.5 crores per day. And the plant we have told you is running at this number. So, in terms of the EBITDA margins at the asset level, we have done 92%, 93% in terms of the EBITDA margins. So, I think this plant is not, when it is fully operational, it will be doing a substantial number better than INR1.5 crores per day. And we have disclosed in the prospectus, the tariff for this plant is roughly INR2.44 per unit. And the expected AC CUF is 30% for this plant.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: So, quarter-on-quarter, what happens is, in terms of the second quarter, right, there is a seasonality impact. Because we have plants across India, including Punjab, including various parts of India, because ours is a distributed portfolio. So, you will see around, I think, 10% sort of revenue difference coming from seasonality. So, on a quarter-on-quarter, but if you look at the next two quarters, there will be no impact of this weather thing. In the second quarter, because of monsoon, you see always, this has been there for not long.
Answer, manoj upadhyay
Manoj Upadhyay: The first quarter, our first quarter, if you compare the ‘24 versus ‘25, FY25 quarter, our CUF has gone up from 23.3% to 24.6%. So, that means we did some operational improvement, for example, like robotic cleaning and other things, because of that, that improvement has happened. Gopal: And, sir, if I see the revenue growth, which you have given like to like, for H1 to H1, the growth is lower than the generation growth. Is there an element of mix of plants? Page 12 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 Nikhil Dhingra: So, it's a function of, see, revenue is a function of units, because as the new plants are coming, they are coming at lower tariffs, right?
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: Yes, yes. One thing which Manoj Ji mentioned is the CUF increase. Other is the, you can say, charging of -- there was some capacity which was added in one of our plants of Aklera project. We had around some capacity which came up in that plant, which was around, which added to -- 50 megawatt. 50 megawatt or so, which was capacity which came up in this half year, in this so, that addition of capacity also happened. Gopal: Okay. And this 1200 megawatt is commissioned now or it will be commissioned?
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: So, there are two phases to this. What happens is that you get a first time charging and then you get a trial run. So, our first time charging has happened of all four plants. And because of which we can sell power to either the PPA purchaser or in case they are giving NOC, we can sell in merchant also. So, we are able to sell power. And that happens post first time charging. Now, there is a commissioning procedure which we are undergoing.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
We are targeting to get it done on 27th, 28th. Post that, it will be commissioned. And post that, pre-commissioning, you get 75% of the tariff also. And post commissioning, you get 100% of the tariff. So, in terms of the next week or so, is our target to get it commissioned, subject to maybe… Because the trial run happens, the sunlight needs to be there. There are a lot of conditions which need to fall in place. So, in terms of the revenue, we are able to recognize the revenue since October.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
We have been generating and selling power to either the off-taker or to the merchant. But in terms of the commissioning, this is expected in the next 10 days or so. Gopal: And whatever revenue we generate, this will be reduced from the cost of project?
Answer, manoj upadhyay
Manoj Upadhyay: Earlier, around 2-3 years back, we used to reduce it from the project cost. But now, because of the change in the laws, we need to take this to the P&L. Gopal: Okay, sure sir. And last bit, can you just explain this GST search which was there? Genesis and what are the implications?
Answer, nikhil dhingra
One is to extend the tenor of that loan which increases the free cash flow to equity for the equity holders. And second is to reduce the interest rate because the lender changes -- the rating of the project also improves. Like in one of the projects we are targeting to take a AA rating, which will be known in a day or two to us. So, which will help us reduce the cost further. And as we have raised equity in our holding company, so we are expecting this to happen more in terms of the improvement in rating at the restricted group or wherever we borrow. So, this refinancing is what we have updated in the presentation. And all three have achieved this purpose of giving us, you can say, debt release for growth.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: So, 8.7 will be the rate which will be at AA. So, we are expecting that kind of rating. So, that is what we have indicated. Because that's a plant which has been operational now for more than 5 Page 14 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 years. It's a group of NTPC, SECI. So, we are expecting a good rating there. And that 8.7 is assuming AA handle.
Question
Nishant Gupta: Hi, sir. Thank you for the opportunity. I had two quick questions. One is, is there any company- specific hurdle rate that you target for a project while bidding for it? I mean, why I'm trying to ask this is because the tariff has fallen to around 2.52. So, that is something. So, just wanted to get a sense what is a sustainable tariff that you enforce while constructing any particular project? That is the first question. And the second one was, how do you see the monetization landscape going forward like are there still opportunities where some of the projects you can exit at a healthy IRR? So, these are two questions/ Nikhil Dhingra: So, in terms of the hurdle rate, as we sai
Answer, nikhil dhingra
And, of course, these hurdle rates we have, of course, an integrated business model which helps us control time and cost. So, it helps us in a bid to get these hurdle rates. In the past also, we have been able to deliver on these hurdle rates. So, that's the sort of hurdle rate we target. In terms of tariff, see, tariff is a function of capex. And, of course, a lot of macroeconomic variables like interest rates and dollar rates because some of the capex is imported and various other things are there in terms of the interest rate because the capex heavy business model. So, we don't target a specific tariff.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
We target a hurdle rate, which is FCFE, IRR, taking the cash flows of the 25 years and also you can say, the cost saving we can achieve through our EPC. So, these two are the sources. We don't take any upsides when we bid in terms of the refinancing rate or a top-up which we can get. These are upsides for us to take, if any. And we keep a contingency of around 10% in the capex which we estimate while doing a project. In terms of the - just to give you an idea on the tariff, you are looking at the solar tariff. These are plain solar bids you are looking at, but when you look at the FDRE projects, the tariffs are in the range of between 4.4 to 4.7 sort of range.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
And we also won a tariff of 4.7 recently with the NTPC bid. And when you look at hybrid, these are in the three handles in terms of 3.3 to 3.4, 3.25 now. So, all these three type of bids and when you look at battery, there are different sort of numbers, plain battery. So, in terms of each of these technology-specific bids, there are various upsides Page 16 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 and downsides possible. You can say in a solar, it's totally dependent on the - you can say the solar, where you are putting up the plant. That will decide the revenue you generate, what sort of capex you are envisaging, whether you have control on land, connectivity. And when you're looking at a high FDRE, there are elements that are slightly higher than a plain solar because you are dealing in three technologies, solar, wind, and battery.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
How are you minimizing the risk possible in the FDRE configuration? So, that's important. Of course, an FDRE offers you an opportunity to have high returns, but also offers you some element of risk. So, there is an interplay of how to minimize the risk and also make the good returns. So, that is why you see in an FDRE project, there are slightly less competitors as compared to a plain solar bid, purely because of the degree of complication in the project. And of course, a plain battery is slightly simpler, so you will see a lot of competition in the plain battery tenders also. So, that is on the hurdle rate.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
In terms of monetization, we don't want to monetize the assets as of now in terms of going forward. We want to consolidate our assets. And also something which we can evaluate in the future is InvIT because that's a semi-monetization sort of a thing, but of course subject to various, whether it makes sense for the shareholders or not, in terms of the listing. Because in terms of our equity requirements, so monetization has been the tool which we have used in the past. Of course, because we were getting good value out of that. And also it helped us raise resources for our capex. And of course, it was the lowest cost of equity which was possible while keeping the whole corporate structure intact.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
And of course, there is a capital gain implication when you sell assets. So, in terms of the mode of fundraising, there are various categories, preferences we have internally. So, where as of now, InvITs scores better than asset sale. If at all we want to go there, we have not yet decided at all to do InvIT or asset sale. But if you want us to compare today, we will rather say InvIT is better than asset sale.
Answer, manoj upadhyay
Manoj Upadhyay: To be very specific to your answer to the question, actually, INR2.51 is not a bad tariff. It is because the capex has come down to the level that it is actually a good tariff.
Question
Nishant Gupta: Got it, sir. I think with the declining solar modules and the cell prices, that is why you are saying that this tariff is sustainable, right?
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Nikhil Dhingra: Yes. The only change which has happened is the modules are now domestic. But there also we are seeing the price parity coming to let's say adjusted for duty. The price parity is almost there. And of course, in all our projects, we can buy cells from China. We do have that flexibility. So, yes.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
And the capex is on a downturn as we are re-emphasizing.
Question
Nishant Gupta: Got it, sir. Just a quick follow-up. Is InvIT something like a year to 2 year kind of a plan or even further than that? Is there a timeline which you have thought about it? Page 17 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 Nikhil Dhingra: No. There is no timeline.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Actually, we are just discussing ideas with you because you dropped an idea. We always don't ignore any idea. So, we like to discuss ideas all the time. So, there is nothing on the table on the InvIT front. So, it's something we have no plan of doing as of now. And we are not planning to do any InvIT as of now because we are able to -- see, InvIT is done for multiple reasons. One is to raise equity, of course.
Answer, nikhil dhingra
Second is to extract cash in terms of every quarter you are able to take yield and all that. So, we don't see any challenge in that in terms of working with our lenders and, of course, getting the refinancings done. So, as of now, there are no compulsions or no drivers for us to attempt an InvIT. So, we have no timeline for it. You can assume it's not on the table. We were just comparing options. When you said monetization, we said there are other options which are there for any company, not for us, for any utility company because it's a two-pronged business.
Question
Nishant Gupta: Got it. Thank you for the detailed answer and all the best.
Answer, manoj upadhyay
Manoj Upadhyay: So, thank you very much for, again, attending the conference, and I hope your queries have been answered. If there are any further queries, my team and our Strategic Growth Advisors will be very happy to share with you. While we are in the growth side, I think you have asked some of those questions where we had a challenge also like GST, which our team handled very well. And one of the learning, I think also it is important for me to share with you that we are doing this 1,200 megawatt project where four projects are getting together. So, the normal synchronization of the plant took more than what we thought of. I think that's also important to share with you. So, fortunately, we are selling the power to the grid at a higher price than it would have been in the PPA.
Answer, manoj upadhyay
But then, again, the timeline, I think it took more than this because this is a very, very large plant, which was getting synchronized four plants together perhaps first time in India. I think also in this business, you must have seen that, in fact, last quarter, especially in the Gujarat area, it has been rained more than what we have expected. Some of you asked questions, why the variation in the revenue? I think July, August, September is normally the season when you see our past track record also, you will find that this season solar is normally lower than the generation. Although, the last quarter has this one. I think some of you also asked on the PPA side. I think some of the PPAs, we thought that should have happened in October, which might happen in this month or in next.
Answer, manoj upadhyay
This thing, because of the election also, we are getting repeated elections in this one. Well, SECI has to go to every state and do that. Sometimes, it goes to some level of Page 18 of 19 ACME Solar Holdings Limited November 25, 2024 approval when the election gets announced and the whole thing gets stopped. I think that's also a learning for all of us that sometimes this can happen. I think the good thing is that we are making good progress on that. Hopefully, as Nikhil was sharing, we should be able to conclude most of the PPAs in the next few weeks or 1 or 2 months. Again, I am very thankful to all of you for this thing.
Questions about this call
- When was the Acme Solar Holdings Q2 FY25 earnings call transcript filed?
- Acme Solar Holdings filed the transcript with the exchange on 29 Nov 2024. This page is built from that transcript.
- What does this page list?
- 58 statements from the transcript across 10 topics, 23 of them with a figure. Each statement is shown with the transcript sentence it came from.
- Are the analysts' questions included?
- Yes. 9 questions and management's answers are listed in the order they were asked, as the transcript prints them.
- Who wrote this page?
- DalalOS Data Desk. Assembled by software from the company's transcript. Not reviewed by a person. How it is made, and what it leaves out, is on the method page linked from the byline.